What does it say that a lower-tier accounting firm wouldn't even complete this garbage process?
What does it say that a lower-tier accounting firm wouldn't even complete this garbage process?
They're not in the big four but they are quite large and well respected, at least they were until they - and BDO, another large accounting firm - were flagged as insufficient in terms of oversight by the UK regulators.
See: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-20/mazars-bd...
So they're on thin ice and they will not risk going down with this particular ship.
I don't know much about European accounting firms. But the rest of your comment seems to contradict your initial claim -- i.e. they are not Big Four and they have had a recent scandal.
If this was a canary in the coalmine it just started wheezing strangely and it looks a little dizzy.
> If this was a canary in the coalmine it just started wheezing strangely and it looks a little dizzy.
sounds like a reason to leave the mine (i.e. there's something really wrong and this is a warning sign).
> sounds like a reason to leave the mine.
Absolutely, if you have funds in this - and any other unaudited - exchange GTFO or you may lose everything. Either their claim that they have the funds is real and you get your money and later you can re-deposit it or you'll be at least not one of the ones left holding the bag.
The big differentiators are the price point and their ability to create an army of consultants on a moments notice where required. The big four clearly have an edge in those cases - at a price.
If Mazars is heading out the door you should try to beat them to the curb.
It doesn't contradict it IMO:
1) In terms of the criticism from the FRC (which I believe is the 'scandal' you are talking about) KPMG were also criticised by the FRC so also would fall foul of this.
2) Just because a company isn't one of the 'big four' doesn't mean that they are lower tier.
Big 4 auditors aren't exactly cheap, but there is a reason why they audit all the major firms. Mazar's biggest customer appears to be the Trump Organization.
I don't think the resources are the real problem.
The real problem is that Mazars has already been cautioned and they know full well that if Binance goes under their reputation is toast if they keep underwriting them.
For example, the smallest of the big4 had $32B just in its audit and accounting section. Mazars had $2B in its entire organization, including advisory.
A large part of my early career in tax was fixing the mistakes made by tax advisors at these two firms.
Those who know, avoid BDO. (And Mazars too. They're actually worse.)
Edit: they do! Maybe they can rebrand as “Emphasast”, to put the emphasis on the past. :D
I disliked working with Deloitte at my first real job, i thought they were asking too much details and putting some useless constraints that had nothing to do with opsec in real life, and that we (me and the manager) had to lightly bullshit through.
Then I worked at a big bank, with an internal audit team, and tbh, I think retrospectively working with Deloitte was the best experience I could have, they are really professional and their price is less surprising to me now. Looking back, i just didn't know better.
It’s possible the USA Big4 will touch a crypto firm and… wherever Binance is based… they won’t.
Generally speaking, if you look hard enough, you could find an auditor that will happily audit your number of nosehairs, or talking parrots, or not ask too many questions about whether or not your shitcoins reserves are actually worth XY billion.
You may need to scrape the bottom of the barrel for that, though.