Congress didn’t want the NIH to have the discretion to refuse to send retired chimps to the haven.
NIH is now saying it knows best. Maybe they do, but it’s not their call.
Thank you Congress for making a clear law!
Congress didn’t want the NIH to have the discretion to refuse to send retired chimps to the haven.
NIH is now saying it knows best. Maybe they do, but it’s not their call.
Thank you Congress for making a clear law!
It's really hard to figure out what to write in legislation. It is also somewhat hard to update the legislation to accord with new but subtle understandings, especially considering how much attention Congress members can possibly have as compared to how much law is in the books (go to a law library, look at a copy of the United States Code without the annotations, and consider how long it would take to read it, and that is only the beginning). But it is better when courts apply the law as written than making stuff up to suit their preferences, constrained by their prior precedents (assuming you are still at a law library, look at a copy of the United States Reports -- all the Supreme Court opinions ever -- and consider how long it would take to read that, and that is only the beginning).
They’re very good at their jobs. Wisconsin laws are very clear, and rarely overturned by courts.
Of course, there’s a downside.
In 2008, the Democrats won a strong trifecta: control of legislature, governorship, and Supreme Court.
In 2009, the Democrats ordered the LRB to draft legislation to gerrymander the state, locking in Democratic rule.
In 2010, the Democrats lost control of the legislature and governorship in 2010. After the census was finished, the Republicans used that legislation for its intended purpose: one party rule.
Now the Republicans have total control of the legislature, and the LRB pops out conservative policy after conservative policy, all at tax-payer expense.
Considering this law was passed, I have to doubt their judgement.