Hacker News Reader

Comment by fjfaase | Hacker News Reader

Please note that this list is for the U.S.A.. If you live in another part of the world, these books might still be copyrighted. For example, in the Netherlands (like most of the EU), it is +70 years, meaning we still have to wait 5 more years.

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_in_public_domain

View on HN

Note that for a number of EU countries, US works are in the public domain once they are PD-US due to the application of the rule of the shorter term.

And in other countries, it's really unlikely you'll end up in prison or sued for using something that is both 75 years old and already public domain elsewhere in the world.

There are a number of books that are based on Winnie-the-Pooh and quoting fragments. For a long time, I have had the idea to write a kind of annotated version of the stories with references to all the books that reference the text.

I understand Disney has the rights to the Winnie-the-Pooh character and that they still might cause trouble for those who publish text from the books in Europe.

None of A. A. Milne's work will enter the PD anywhere in the EU until 2027, including all the elements of his character Winnie the Pooh, not counting elements introduced by other writers who added more later.

It's about equally unlikely that you'll end up in prison or sued for downloading copyrighted content in the United States, especially if it is PD elsewhere. In fact, if it is PD elsewhere, the chances of your being prosecuted for downloading it approach zero.

Works passing into the public domain have very little to do with people actually getting practically slapped around for downloading them. But they have EVERYTHING to do with creating derivative works. If you create a film based on a book that is PD-US but still copyrighted in the EU, you can expect to get sued.

PD terms also affect legal libraries and archive significantly.

Germany forced Project Gutenberg to take down a few books for Germans who used the site a couple years ago, despite the site being entirely operated from the US.

Sounds reasonable.

It's not reasonable for someone to assume liability in a country they don't operate in.

Did they block German traffic? And thats not snark: English gambling sites used to have to block US traffic

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29024039 for an earlier discussion and details about this.

Some works from that era still have publishers enforcing the copyright wherever they can. I remember some disputes about the Sherlock Holmes books which expired in life + 70 countries but were still under copyright in the USA.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com