He does have some great insights here and there - take the first movement of the tempest sonata:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIQH9OVH_MM
You can feel the raw wind in that.
If you don't like Gould for Bach may I suggest Dinu Lipatti?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7PNFDrcqmY
And if you had not heard about him maybe dive a bit deeper and see what else you like, he's an amazing pianist that unfortunately was born before really great quality recordings were made but what's there is well worth listening to. His '(unfortunately)Last Recital' is a masterpiece. Enjoy!
Indeed! These compositions were ...composed "for the profit and use of musical youth desirous of learning, and especially for the pastime of those already skilled in this study".[1], which I don't think is directly mentioned in the article except maybe from this quote by Gould:
> ...“according to the musical disposition of that day, he was generations behind it”.
It takes skill to play these compositions the way they were written. Piano is not my forte but what effort I have put into learning these tunes was well worth it.
> If you don't like Gould for Bach may I suggest Dinu Lipatti?
When I compare the two different performers, Gould sounds like he's playing to a metronome and Dinu Lipatti is playing to a pendulum.
> And if you had not heard about him maybe dive a bit deeper and see what else you like, he's an amazing pianist that unfortunately was born before really great quality recordings were made but what's there is well worth listening to. Enjoy!
Thank you for sharing.
Usually people complain - listening to the earlier version - that Gould plays fast and loose with the source. He makes opinionated choices throughout and even recomposes parts!
All that being said, there are no wrong answers with this stuff. If you prefer it more freely played than Gould 62, that's perfectly valid and no music expert (worth listening to) will bat an eye. This thread has some good suggestions of other interpreters you may like more.
The irony of your "player piano" statement is that his famous 1955 Goldberg variations were redone by a company called Zenph to demonstrate the power of their software to re-perform any performance. Probably Gould was chosen because he's so famous and I _think_ the recording was in the public domain and convenient, but also Gould actually has a lot of idiosyncrasies that make his playing instantly recognizable and if anything more human.
That's a nice technical accomplishment (and probably it was very hard to get it to this stage). It makes me wonder if you had had Gould on a Yamaha Disklavier and recorded the MIDI stream how the two would compare.
The biggest difference is that I'm sure if you introduced Gould to the world of MIDI and DAWs he probably wouldn't stop fiddling with it for months or years. Even back in the 60s and 70s I think he was well known to obsess over his recordings, and his practice of occasionally splicing performances to get the best from each take was/is pretty controversial. The irony also being that he was notoriously a pain to record because he often sang overtop his playing.
Super interesting man and amazing pianist, extremely opinionated and definitely not to everybody's taste. Some of his work I love and some of it I can't listen to without being irritated so I get why there are people that do not like it at all.
That's jazz, baby
I find many of Bach's music simultaneously "robotic" (brainiac, rational, calculating, etc) and extremely emotional at the same time and for me, that's one of the main draws of his music.