If 90% of tutanota-orginated emails are fraudulent, tutanota is an excellent fraud indicator, even though it will block legitimate emails.
If 10% of gmail-originated emails are fraudulent, gmail is a terrible fraud indicator, even though it will let fraudulent emails pass through, possibly more than the count of fraudulent emails coming from tutanota.
I wonder why so many companies drag their feet when implementing actually useful anti-fraud measures (like supporting Verified-by-Visa) and instead block random email providers.
Most ecommerce merchants are non-technical, and utilise 3rd party platforms (Shopify, Bigcommerce etc) that in combination with their Payment Gateway don't support these systems.
I can safely say that every order my business has received with a Tutanota address has turned out to be fraud. It is a really strong indicator for a fraudulent transaction.
There are many other signals, but for some reason this is a really strong one.
We see a similar trend with Aleeas, and Simplelogin.
We still get fraud from Gmail and Outlook addresses, but it is picked up using other indicators, IP, IP owner, Shipping Address, phone number reachability, carrier, Payment Methods, name, useragent, "for lease" or "for sale" status of the delivery address etc etc...
Yet for some reason they're not already using gmail, meaning as far as frausters are concerned there is a benefit to using tutanota.
> and all you accomplished is that you inconvenienced legit Tutanota users.
No what you've accomplished is reduce tutanota fraud to 0, and inconvenienced frausters.
But that is hardly relevant.
The question is, does blocking Tutanota reduce total fraud, or does it just make fraudsters to move to a different email hoster and you end up with the same total fraud?
You don't just block tutanota, you block a big, long list of high-abuse email sources, periodically updated.
Then again, maybe I am overestimating fraudsters, and by blocking email hosts that make it too easy to sign up you can get rid of a significant chunk of them...
A lot of them are just stuffing stolen credit card numbers to try to find which ones still work, anyway, so they don't care about breaking into your system in particular, they just want to find any system that will let them attempt a charge. If they're finding enough of those using cheap or free anonymous accounts from low-credibility email address providers, they have no reason to spend more time or effort on it.
Blocking these providers doesn't mean you won't still see better-targeted fraud attempts, but it cuts down on a ton of the low-effort but high-volume automated crap—and that stuff can kill a merchant payment processing account in a weekend, if you're not pretty good at blocking it.