Stop-losses are one mechanism for implementing that, but they are crude, and big players don't actually use them. In that regard, she was correct. For one thing, if you trade size, you don't want to dump everything with a marketable order at once, you have to scale out even if you are wrong. Secondly, some strategies will always perform worse if you add stop loss levels, notably mean reversion. But they can make sense, for instance, for trend following, because there are clear levels at which you can say that a trend has ended. Lastly, high-frequency traders like market-making firms, which Alameda was supposed to be, don't use stop loss orders, because they are not trying to take directional bets, they are just trying to capture the spread while keeping their book balanced.
Also, it's a psychological thing: traders think in risk. If they were mistaken with a trade idea, they close the position with a small loss. Easy, just move on to the next!
But when a position is already deep in the reds, it becomes increasingly harder to press the "close"-button and realize the loss.
I know somebody who lost a few hundred grand just a few weeks ago because he was unable to close the position. He didn't set an initial stop loss, and then started believing in his trade (or the company) too much, although the market was telling him otherwise. He started doing dollar cost averaging and other stupid stuff. Actually, this guy is incredibly smart, but became too attached. I feel genuinely sorry for him. But that's what happens, when you don't have the discipline.
But the lack of complete protection is a pretty bad argument against using the available protection.
(There's some things a stop-limit is better for than a regular stop loss, but I'm not convinced that they are generally superior except in the technical sense that any stop loss can be issued as a stop-limit with a $0 limit.)
When I was writing trading systems, it was a big headache to modify a system original designed only for equities to handle other asset types, especially those that could have negative prices.
Better yet, use proper algebraic data types.
Even in 2020, some popular trading platforms failed to handle when oil futures went negative! Opportunity for the prepared, I suppose.
EDIT: Oh and saw your follow-up -- we used 0 to represent "market" which is clearly broken in this scenario. Works fine for positive-only prices though :)
We had one bespoke protocol for communicating between the order management system (conceptually a high-reliability database that holds order state and communicates with components connected to exchanges) and the trading engines (higher code churn rate, and can recover order state from the order management systems if they need to be restarted, so less critical). When we created a second version of the order management system, we created a wholly new bespoke messaging protocol where every field was optional with a default value, and had an unfortunate feature that if one side set a field in a message to the default for that data type, the messaging layer would size-optimize the messages by removing that field. Combined with encoding order amendments as messages where all of the unchanged fields were removed, it meant that if an order ever had a field amended to a default value, the other side of the communication would interpret it as no change, and would acknowledge the message but not amend the value.
It wasn't a big deal for a lot of the order paremeters that got thrown into a single customization string, since it probably wasn't actually possible to amend on order to become completely vanilla (upstream systems tacked on some customizations between receiving the order from the customer and presenting the order to the OMS).
However, amending a price to zero would result in this space-saving optimization, and the trading engine would interpret it as no change in price. The API did have separate calls for getting a field value (which would transparently return the default value for missing fields) and for checking if a value was actually specified. Though, due to the "optimization" in the messaging layer, checking of a value was specified was really just a check if the returned value was equal to the default value.
This is false. In the context of high volume trading (which we are discussing here), a naive stop loss will obliterate any profits you might accrue with your strategy. Execution of your stop loss will simply eat through the whole order book and give you the worst possible price for your exit.
A loss of 10 percent necessitates an 11 percent gain to recover. Increase that loss to 25 percent and it takes a 33 percent gain to get back to break-even. A 50 percent loss requires a 100 percent gain to recover and an 80 percent loss necessitates 500 percent in gains to get back to where the investment value started.
There are other ways to exit a position.
A stop loss could be set at a threshold that isn’t so tight to lose money on normal variations, low enough if it’s acceptable to take the loss and and capture and deploy the capital elsewhere, and not too low to never be triggered.
A "stop loss" does not mean the same thing as "exiting a position to cut your losses". There are other ways to exit a position. If you have a large position, then exiting via market order (which is what a stop loss does) is going to give the worst possible price for your exit.
A stop-loss-limit is better in that it makes the potential consequence of a stop-loss more clear: You could set a stop loss limit order with a limit of $0 to create a standard stop loss-- making it explicit that you're willing to potentially sell the asset for $0/share: which is what a stop loss is willing to do. (+/- market circuit breakers, which generally don't exist in cryptocurrency markets.)
If it's not immediately apparent why stop losses are a hazard: When markets are volitile the supply of standing orders near the spread tends to thin out-- for some assets, like the worthless magic beans FTX and friends specialized in owning, the markets are never particularly thick. What a stop loss order will do is once the market ticks below your threshold it will dump into a market order. Market prices are not continuous. If someone sold at $100 that doesn't mean you can sell at $100-- a market sale might be at $80-- locking in a substantial loss that otherwise would have been a momentary blip and never impacted you. These orders essentially automate one of the worst practices of inexperienced investors that result in loss: panicking at every dip and selling at a loss when nothing fundamental has changed.
What joe-sixpack thinks a stop loss will do is guarantee him a floor price. It will not. Joe could buy put contracts to create a guaranteed floor price but they cost money-- that cost is a direct sign of how much stop loss orders do not work.
A stop-loss-limit at $100/$100 would do what was expected if it executes but it usually won't execute except when the price dips and then recovers-- the case where you would have preferred to have your stop loss not exist at all. Seldom do people want a "Sell my stuff at $100/share if the price gets under $100 but only when it recovers"-- that would probably only be justifiable to the extent that the drop showed your thesis about the investment was wrong. Fundamentally the guarantee people want here can only be had at a price, and paying that price is a reasonable part of risk management.
If you're trading very small amounts of very liquid items on highly surveilled and regulated markets then perhaps you can get away with using them without getting too greatly burned. But at the same time puts for the same assets are usually fairly inexpensive. In the cryptocurrency sphere it's just not that unlikely that 'exchanges' (particularly bucket shops like FTX where the exchange is substantially the counterparty in the activity) has some script that counts up all the users stop loss orders and figures out how much profit they could make causing a momentary blip in the trading price just to trigger them. There are plenty of people in the industry that don't believe it would be unlawful to do so, seeing as how the traded assets aren't securities.
(and IIRC long before FTX's collapse there was a lawsuit alleging that they engaged in that kind of manipulation)
So mocking the stop loss comment seems a bit misplaced, but it's worth noting that the question was really about risk management and she didn't give a useful answer to the intended question either-- especially since the rubbish they owned was hard to impossible to risk manage and for good reason.
Presumably i bought because I thought it was worth more than $100, it would only make sense for me to sell at $80 for a reason other than the price: fundamentals change, some bad event happening. If the only thing that changed is the price, I want to buy more at $80!