The truly innovative startups, the ones every investor wishes they were in on the ground floor of (Google, FB, Twitter, ...) could not have been summarized as "the X of Y" before their introduction.
Meh. Google was "yahoo search but simpler/better", FB was "myspace but non-customisable". Twitter is arguably more innovative, but could be summarised as "the texting of internetz".
Do any of those descriptions really do a good job at selling? If I heard any of those back in the day, I would have said "so what?" The answer to that so-what should be the pitch.