Anyone who chose to enable the option "Show dead" (comments/submissions) in the settings can still see the title and vouch for it if they like.
To me, there’s nothing more powerful than someone posting a contrarian perspective and there being a highly upvoted, well-reasoned/cited response as to why the contrarian perspective isn’t valid. This I would prefer over having those contrarian perspectives suppressed, and I never get to see or engage with them.