The question of interpreting quantum mechanics is quite different. We do not have a popular mathematical framework that clearly explains why we perceive a classical world while being "inside" of a quantum wavefunction. There is plenty of vagueness and oversimplification in that last statement, but the difference is "we have an abstraction that explains mostly-perfectly EM waves and we do not care about whether people are comfortable with the abstraction" vs "we do not even have a mathematical abstraction explaining why we perceive a classical world inside of a quantum universe".
It’s pretty easy for me to imagine things bumping into each other because I see that happening all around me
Wait, what? What do they do then? My physical science education ended in high school.
The real answer is that constituent parts of bound states like atoms don't really exist as separate things. An atom is a particular very complicated field configuration, and if you want anything deeper than that you're going to have to learn QFT.
When I think of chemistry, it seems like even if there's some sense in which the bound atom is one big writhing mass of fields, the whole atom doesn't interract in a uniform way with the outside, right? The electrons interract with the outside a lot, the nucleus is harder to get to?
Is it wrong to say the layer of my onion exist as separate entities, when they seem to interract largely independently from the core of the onion, like they do in metals and chemistry?
(I guess the answer is still "you're going to have to learn QFT" :) But the next falsehood down seems fun to ask about too!)
Some of both. Valence electrons in a conductor are delocalized over the entire surface.
> When I think of chemistry, it seems like even if there's some sense in which the bound atom is one big writhing mass of fields, the whole atom doesn't interract in a uniform way with the outside, right? The electrons interract with the outside a lot, the nucleus is harder to get to?
Right, at least for stable atoms at low energy scales.
What I mean is that the mechanism by which sound travels is the same as the mechanism by which I can punch a punching bag and see it swing.
Even if the two materials never “come into contact” because it’s actually the result of charges repelling each other or whatever, the way it works in both cases is the same.
What I suspect you want, however, is some sort of substance or essential nature that makes the thing go. If that's the case, then the answer is that there are no such things. Not for light, not for ordinary classical mechanics, not for anything. Physical systems are what they do.
People have been doing this since pre-helenics, "what is the medium where everything operates" or along the questions of "what is the medium that contains vacuum".
It's not that anyone isn't trying to understand that, it's just that thinking about unprovable things is boring and uninteresting from science point of view. At that level we may as well accept we all live in the Rabbit's Hole with Magic.
> He realised that a changing electric field could create a changing magnetic field, which would then create another electric field and so on. The result would be a self-sustaining electromagnetic field, endlessly repeating, travelling incredibly fast.
https://cosmosmagazine.com/science/physics/what-is-light/
It’s generally studied in undergraduate E&M courses.
Now if you’re curious about how E or M fields propagate you’ll start getting into quantum again. Generally this leads up to quantum electrodynamics, where as I understand it everything is treated as fields and interactions as particles.
How those fields propagate is the same as asking how wave functions “travel”. We simply don’t have to tools to even ask the right questions, IMHO.
"All the electrons that are in your body are not fundamental. All the electrons that exist in your body are waves of the same underlying field."
The next question is, if there are no individual things, what does math count? http://www.katabane.com/mt/ontology.html
You can only measure (compare) something in relation to something else.
If everything is homogeneous there are no measures, no clocks, and no way you could count anything.
And if numbers represent the things we seem to perceive (discrete, fundamental things), though our science demonstrates that individual things are illusory.
The fun part is that the science which demonstrates the illusory nature of the things that math counts is dependent on the math.
Classical theories don't have this problem.
And of course what gravity has to do with it.