> Does anyone find socioeconomic status ( SES ) so broad a label that it is almost useless catch all category for whatever data you actually want to capture?
Its true that SES is operationalized somewhat differently in different studies, so that conclusions about it one study may not transfer directly to what is studied under that name in another study. The operationalization here (and this is not uncommon) is, additionally, using summary measure is itself somewhat obfuscatory unless the summary measure captures a complex relationship distinct from the individual contributions of the components, which does not clearly seem to be the case here.
I wouldn’t say that SES is useless, but I would say that it seems to have no utility here separate from studying the individual components of that are used in operationalizing it.