I am attempting (poorly) to emphasize that this conversation requires more nuance.
It is possible to be pro-privacy while simultaneously understanding why it is sometimes necessary to reveal private information.
I understand what you're saying, and I also would love a middle-ground.
However, as the article explains better than I could, there's no way to get the upsides of privacy while mitigating the downsides.
We have system for that. Court tells you to do it or else you're punished.
Or a "secret" court does the same...
Not sure why your post was downvoted. There is a difference between asking customers voluntarily on your ecommerce site to say pass an AVS check or have an IP address in the same country that their card is from (in my view reasonable) and requiring all communications to go through mediums that the government can read (in my view unfeasible and invasive).