If they said that 'I think would get around X after more job search but I'll settle with 0.95X for a quick offer', I'd be thankful for the information and consider the deal. If they said that 'I want X because that's the amount I'd be free of jealousy/resent/etc.', I'd be glad they shared the not completely rational but honest emotional reason behind their preference and also consider the deal.
Using the 'fair' card means that 'if you don't agree you are unfair therefore you're a bad person'.
So I recommend everyone to unpack what 'fair' means to them and explain that thing instead of using the word 'fair'.
My strategy is generally quite extreme transparency, especially in cases when we're at the beginning of a long-term relationship.