John Mashey on RISC/CISC (1991)
userpages.umbc.edu
userpages.umbc.edu
More goodies: https://yarchive.net/comp/index.html
No they aren't. In 'real life', games, especially high resource games, are inconsequential compared to, say, performance of Excel, Word or web browsing for the overwhelmingly majority of users.
On the other hand, measuring on, say, protein folding isn't likely to gather a lot of interest because most people are not buying laptops to run HPC research.
So, ultimately the reason videogames (and video encoding, compression, image processing and a few other workloads) are chosen is because they are workloads where the CPU really makes a difference and is interesting to the average reader if not because it's their problem, at least because they are close enough to be understandable.
(A separate 10 page post would be required to dig into the GPU role and impact of those tests)
This happened to look right in 1991 because SPARC and MIPS were riding high at that moment in history. Both would fall behind x86 a few years later.
And more to the point: this only looks right at this particular moment because Intel fell off the edge and Apple jumped ahead with a TSMC-manufactured part. But that's almost entirely down to process technology. If Intel was using TSMC's process then it's likely that the M1 switchover never would have happened.
And in any case you're wrong on the facts. The M2 and Zen 3 cores are not being fabbed on the same process; AMD is still on 7nm for its CPU products vs. 5nm for Apple. Their use of 5nm is exclusively for GPUs so far.
(The E variety of RISC-V is also a bit strange in having only 16 integer registers, but the rationale for that was supporting smaller chips and easier extensibility; it's still very clearly a load-store architecture where compute happens within registers. Arguably, compilers have also gotten better at staying within fewer registers and not spilling to memory. So "number of registers" as a criteria might have shifted a little bit.)
Makes sense as a hardware designer to be able to pick a power- and space-efficient chip.
Mashey also had thoughts about that: https://yarchive.net/comp/mips16.html
Likewise for atomic operations: https://yarchive.net/comp/ll_sc.html
They will have a third very soon. The encoding space for 4-byte instructions is almost spent.
John Mashey on RISC/CISC - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9811397 - July 2015 (4 comments)
Others?
One thing isn’t - 5a, unaligned access. Some modern RISCs allow this, probably because there’s enough code out there that does it.