Even if we assumed the interventions would work we have a current wave of low-to-medium level crime and we need a current solution for people who are being arrested 100+ times per year, and/or avoid all arrest by staying under unwritten minimums of damage. If dealt with they have to be put somewhere and if the default is to build maximum security prisons, that's what we'll do, or maybe just over-stuff the ones we have making them more dangerous.
If we did build low-level prisons we'd not only have a solution for the interim, but it'd be an improvement over current conditions. I think they'd not only handle the new crime, but could pull non-violent offenders from the existing prisons as well - reducing overcrowding and better handling the actual danger the prisoners pose.
> Incarceration is an expensive way to not really solve the problem of crime.
Sure, and fire trucks don't solve fire. But both are part of the solution.
> addressing people's basic needs
What about crime that's not caused by poverty or need, like rape? There'll always be a need to lock people up.
I share the goal of lowering that number but I can't see how it gets to zero.
> and had better mental and healthcare we'd see less crime
Prisons aren't alone in not working as intended - that award goes to most one-size-fits-all government programs.
Those interventions aren't actually likely to solve the problem. They'll misdiagnose the problem, pick a horrible solution, and fail to execute properly anyways. I've seen this first hand with drug policy and addiction treatment. Our over-funded system is the most dangerous place to be. An addict on the streets of some poor city in the middle of nowhere has better outcomes.