If you want idea protection you need to look at patents.
If you want idea protection you need to look at patents.
Arguing that AI is mining ideas and not expressions is going to be a lot less successful when you've got a large pool of expert witnesses who are going to be able and willing to say that AI is only capable of mimicking the form of what it sees.
Yes, when you train on a human generated corpus you're going to get an interpolative AI. But when you train on a dataset generated by AI, you can surpass human level.
AlphaZero started, as the name says, from zero. No examples of how we play the game. In just three days of self-play it surpassed the best human. How was that possible? We got a 2000 year head start, larger brains, and many players, not just one model. AlphaZero did it by creating its own training data.
Here is an example of using code language models for this kind of dataset-creation by play.
> Evolution through Large Models
https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.08896
By the way, GPT-3 and chatGPT are not simple interpolative language models. They have also been trained on many tasks, problems, and codes, which is the kind of data that will awaken the skills of the model to a whole new level. What I am saying is that we can auto-generate more problem data and increase their skills.
If Bob wrote a program that took Sally's dataset and produced source code from prompts, that too would in principle not violate copyright and he could sell that.
But you're suggesting that if one person did both at once, that would violate copyright?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_....
This is what I would argue if I was Microsoft's lawyer. You can't win a copyright lawsuit over one bar of music, one dance move, or a few words. Similarly, copilot can't be considered to be infringing on anyone's copyright because the snippets it might copy verbatim are too short to be copyrightable.
Actually... The smallest successful copyright claim is I believe over 10 words or so.
However, this definitely pushed the boundaries of copyright law. Audi never appealed the $1m verdict, so it's hardly settled case law.
Actually, Kraftwerk did
https://www.factmag.com/2019/07/30/kraftwerk-sample-lawsuit-...
There are bands that are giving all of the profits of entire albums to the people whose sample they failed to clear on a single song.
No. You can't.
https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/can-you-patent-an-idea
'A machine sucking dust from a surface in order to clean it' is an idea.
Dyson design is an invention.
https://www.dyson.com/vacuum-cleaners/cordless/v15/detect/ye...
Here a broad description of differences between copyright and patent (trademark included):
https://copyrightalliance.org/faqs/difference-copyright-pate...
None of them covers the principle of idea.
And if you want an example of a dubious (in my opinion) attempt to patent an idea (patent troll):
https://patents.google.com/patent/EP3811791A1/en
While is it a patent trolling attempt (in my opinion) ?
Because it's basically an idea (adding a natural compound in ecigarette eliquids as sweetener) with an extensive list of layers covering general principles of everything related to ecigarette and ecigarette eliquid to pretend it's a specific formula (which is not) or an invention (which is neither because it's a natural compound known for its sweetener properties since 19th century).