If we can't trust rsync.net to not do that then how can we trust them to actually stop producing canaries after the gag order? Is it something to do with how they are produced?
It is to prevent 'pregenerated' message. Also increases the entropy of the message vs just a simple date change.
> If we can't trust rsync.net to not do that then how can we trust them to actually stop producing canaries after the gag order?
Elsewhere in thread it was discussed that, legally compelling someone NOT TO say something is somewhat easier than compelling them TO say something.
As an interesting theory, if they were somehow 'compelled' by a court order to say they were OK for X weeks, they could just pregen the next X weeks without headlines, which would possibly be another way for the canary to squawk.
Closing stock price of multiple stocks.
This week's powerball numbers.
Count of babies born in several hospitals on a specific day.
The current nytimes headlines.
The most recent close of the largest stock markets.
The last power balls numbers.
Most of those would be valuable in their own right if you had foreknowledge.
I understand that in this scenario we trust rsync.net and are afraid of secret warrants. If rsync.net wanted to deceive is, they could do that by... just lying? What incentives do they have to pregenerate these messages?
I have high confidence that the individual tasked with this can quickly think of another unpredictable metric with which to datestamp the canary.