I disagree, but given that it's a subjective technical decision I don't think we're going to be able to find any kind of objective call as to what the right decision was.
The problem is that all technical decisions involve balancing the requirements of multiple parties and if your ethical framework is "Gnome is all volunteers they can do what they want" that makes them completely immune to any sort of criticism. Yes, I concede that they are free to do whatever they want, but that doesn't free them from criticism.
But hey, if you want to come up with some kind of objective moral framework for us to work in that's fine.
>Subjective as in, not based in any provable facts.
Do you think that the choice to not implement XDG-decoration is based on probable facts? Because it is also a subjective call. Maybe go read some lesswrong until you have a better handle on how to deal with subjectivity in debate: https://www.lesswrong.com/rationality