What is their motivation even when company policy states otherwise?
The cost to the company of a single employee injury or death sustained while stopping a shoplifter is probably equivalent to hundreds of single-person personal thefts. Even if there’s never any workers l-comp-esque payouts, the hours of administrative time spent reviewing and investigating the incident probably costs more than a dozen thefts.
You have one store where employees don't stop thieves.
You have another store where thieves are stopped by security and those who are caught have their hand chopped off.
A couple questions: 1) Is theft reduced 2) If theft is not reduced, does theft at least decrease at handless-thief store in favor of store that does nothing.
It's not hard for me to imagine that having say a hand chopped off even once can lead to hundreds of less thefts at a store.
My humble conjecture. Not saying hands should be chopped.