Maybe the answer to the Fermi Paradox (or 'Where the hell are they?') is that they're around and doing interstellar drive-bys and we're just starting to notice.
Maybe the answer to the Fermi Paradox (or 'Where the hell are they?') is that they're around and doing interstellar drive-bys and we're just starting to notice.
If a species had a mere 1 million year technological lead on us, they’d certainly have nothing to fear and would only need to do a drive by every ten-thousand years or so, to keep tabs on things.
Perhaps more concerning is that we could be in between two competing species and they’re monitoring to make sure the other hasn’t colonized this system.
When it comes to aliens there are many possibilities, and few of them are good for us imo.
Or not. To paraphrase: sometimes a cigar-shaped interstellar mass is just a cigar-shaped interstellar mass.
also, might you presume such possibilities are rarely good for us because of implicit recognition how bad we humans are to other species?
1. The cost of interstellar travel is so obscenely high that the threat posed by the discovery of an alien species on their home planet would be so miniscule to us and them
2. The cost of remotely annihilating an entire species is so absurdly high as to be obviously impractical and basically impossible.
[Spoiler alert] The Dark Forest by Liu Cixin renders all of this irrelevant by the use of science fiction: it purports the existence of interstellar world-destroying weapons that any lowly member of a species can casually "flick" at a "star plucker" to obliterate them. That is not how physics or reality works.
We don't even send our trash to space because just getting it out of Earth's orbit is so ridiculously expensive, yet we're thinking about sending enough explosives to destroy an entire civilization some 100+ light-years away?
A handful of people today can casually "flick" entire cities out of existence, and enough such flicks could eradicate our species, and even if not it would certainly eradicate many. That would have been an absurd notion to somebody a thousand years ago. But the idea that we'll be able to destroy stars just as easily in a million years is somehow just fiction?
This thinking along the lines of "things in the past that were believed to be impossible are now possible, therefore things in the future that we now believe impossible may actually happen" is pretty poor reasoning. In the past, our understanding of the fundamental laws of physics was quite lacking. Today, although it is incomplete, our understanding of physics is considerably more advanced to preclude a lot of physically impossible things.
To me this just sound like a combination of hubris and lack of imagination. Sure, our understanding of physics advanced so much in the last few centuries. Relatively.
I'm sure we're at least like 20% of the way towards cracking the puzzle of how the whole universe actually works; there's just some kinks to work out, right? /s
The way I view history, in a thousand years everything we "know" now might look like nothing more than once-useful, semi-accurate models for describing the behavior of a tiny little subsystem of what reality actually is. Or, more likely, we won't even remeber why the models of today were ever useful, and the average person (assuming there are still separete "people") will flippantly refer to the scientists of today idiots.
500 years ago your argument would have been: We cant even get to china in 12 weeks without considerable danger and expense, and you expect me to believe its routine for peasants to do so in 12 hours? That anyone can make a near perfect painting and send it to anyone else no matter where they are in a heartbeat - we don't even make bad paintings of anyone who isn't extremely rich because of the absurd expense of it.
The analogy with the the argument 500 years ago doesn't apply because 500 years ago we did not have the understanding of physics and chemistry that we have today. Of course we still have a lot of physics left to discover, but it's extremely unlikely that whatever new physics we discover will violate special relativity.
A 100kg probe at 10% of the speed of light is about the energy of a 20 megaton nuke. Another 20 megatons to slow it down.
It seems very likely that the technology necessary will be developed in the next 100-10,000 years.
How could any government possibly convince their citizens that this is the best use of trillions of tax dollars (if not quadrillions of dollars), not to mention how can we create a 1,000kg device that can categorically annihilate an entire planet? If the Dark Forest theory is indeed true, why haven't we seen evidence of such galactic levels of destruction? The Milky Way has been around for over 10 billion years. Surely by then there must've been at least one civilization advanced enough to do this in that time. Yet we see no evidence for this whatsoever.
The more you spell this out, the more absurd it becomes from any practical perspective.
Our destruction of the environment is different also. Cutting down the Amazon is a side-effect of our pursuit of natural resource. We do not go there with the intention of killing all of the species there. That is just an unfortunate consequence of our hunt for resources.
The Dark Forest is entirely different. The entire thesis of that theory is an advanced civilization would have the singular goal of sterilizing all other life in the galaxy as the goal in and of itself. There is simply nothing analogous to that in human history.
Devoted years worth of total resource production to kill each other by the millions over a few square miles of resource poor land.
That was such a popular hit that we threw a sequel that was even more costly.
As a result of the sequel we had several major empires devote trillions of dollars to making sure that we could annihilate our own species just in case one of the others also tried to annihilate the species first. This caused the collapse of at least one empire. People regularly call for the use of these annihilation weapons and it's sheer dumb luck that it hasn't happened yet.
Speaking of annihilation - there have been several large scale attempts at exterminating all humans that fit xyz criteria in the last century. Mostly these are not based on anything other than "exists with DNA slightly different than our own". It seems likely that "exists with way different DNA" and even "exists with a different building block than DNA" could be used as criteria.
If you don't limit yourself to intelligent species, humans have carried out large scale attempts at exterminating several native species. Some I'm aware of in the last couple centuries:
Wolf eradication programs paying bounties per dead wolf.
Same for the american bison. (this one is special because it was also intentionally an attempt to genocide native folks by starvation).
The "smash sparrow" campaign in china - kill all the sparrows because of a misunderstanding of what food they eat.
I guess I could buy your premise that humans wouldn't participate in the dark forest for logical reasons is semi-believable IFF we ignore the things humans actually do.
Give me an example of modern times and now we're talking.
All of the examples you said are so limited in scale to what the Dark Forest actually requires: complete sterilization of all life in the galaxy. To go from "killing bison" to exterminating all forms of life is a gargantuan leap.
I hope I am wrong of course.
The reasoning that "there's a non-zero chance that if we don't, someone else will do it to us" is practically useless reasoning, especially from a policy perspective. That's like saying that the laws of quantum mechanics prescribe a non-zero probability to a planet-sized nuclear bomb materializing next to Earth and instantly exploding, demolishing all life here, yet we don't make policies based on such vanishingly low probability events.
Plus is every sentient species going to be this genocidal by nature? Humans do have a history genocide, but in civilized society today, we do everything we can to avoid war. The United States clearly has the military might to invade any number of nations in the world and easily conquer them, yet we don't for a whole host of totally valid and logical reasons. Heck, we pass laws (I assume for good and justifiable moral reasons) to protect indigenous people even though we have the might to completely obliterate them.
Everything about the Dark Forest is completely impractical when thought through with the smallest amount of sensible reasoning.
Alien life might realize this, that the probability is very high that other life forms really don't care about the continued reproductive success of other life forms, unless there is some lopsided benefit involved. Maybe they aren't even consuming their own resources to act on this goal of wiping out the possibility, however low, of a danger to their species emerging. Maybe they've already sent out some AI controlled probes, that are on distant metal rich asteroids far from their homeworld, autonomously mining, building weaponry, identifying targets, and launching these weapons that will hit their targets millions or billions of years in the future. Such implementation could even outlast the species that initially created it.
Secondly, the thought of unleashing a civilization-destroying self-replicating AI into the galaxy is so dangerous that I doubt any civilization would do it. Imagine the dangers of that. All it takes is for the AI to misidentify you as "another" civilization and wipe you out, or for these AI to be taken over by another party and turned against you, or for the AI to actually just misidentify you and kill you. The dangers of that far outweigh the benefits in the miniscule chance that the Dark Forest is in fact real.
It's entirely possible we will come up with a different theory which is largely consistent with much of what we do know, while still allowing for things that we currently think are impossible.
We know so very, very little.
That species, left unchecked, could fill up its galaxy in the blink of an eye, by galactic timescales.
For such a civilization, I think talking about the 'cost' of things is somewhat of an abstract idea because advanced automation is surely possible for them. Once I am capable of producing a self-replicating machine capable of strong-AI level cognition all I have to do is release one at the frontier of my empire, instruct it to seed itself as widely as it can, build up massive stockpiles of processed resources and energy, and await further instructions. Such a network would be capable of nearly arbitrary levels of resource utilization, all of which could be redirected into wiping out my cosmic neighbors, since my species's immediate needs are satisfied by a similar post-scarcity system.
If I am capable of such a thing and I choose not to employ the strategy of ruthlessly exterminating all life of which I am aware I run the risk of someone else developing this technology and doing the same to me.
The only possible scenario where this doesn't hold water is if it's somehow advantageous to long-term survival of both parties to cooperate and exchange technology rather than spend resources annihilating each other. I think even the simplest game theory analysis will tell us that can't possibly be true.
There are way too many assumptions baked into what you wrote to make that the only possible scenario where the Dark Forest is incorrect.
You basically assume that the benefits of this outweigh the costs, which is entirely unfounded. You also assume that the technology for this is possible. Just saying "imagine something millions (heck I'll give you billions given how old the Milky Way is) of years more advanced than us" does not logically necessitate any of these assumptions to be true.
And if the Dark Forest is so obviously true, why hasn't it happened yet? Why are we still alive? For a 10 billion year-old galaxy, you'd imagine there's at least one other sentient species out there capable of such technology (if such technology is even ever possible in this universe, which is not yet proven of course). If you believe in the Dark Forest, then you must be indiscriminate about your killing, since one key tenet of the theory is technological explosion. A hairy ape (or even a small rodent) today may be harmless but given millions of years, could be the most intelligent species in the galaxy. So taking this to its logical end would require you to kill all life (even bacteria) whenever it's detected.
It's a big galaxy. It still probably takes a while to get around to "cleaning up" our sleepy part of the galaxy.
What if the risk of allowing another alien species to progress is so absurdly high that vast resources are allocated to create WMD to annihilate them. Then it does become trivially easy unless there’s a MAD/detente system. That’s pretty much the point of the book.
The launch of a working BvN probe is basically a permanent phase change for a galaxy.
The snowflake hypothesis is at least in the range of the "things we can't disprove", at least if by "snowflake" you mean neutron star surfaces: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg Of course, one must consider that I'm citing a science fiction book, with all understanding of what that means. But that is at least one hypothesis I don't think we can disprove at the current time, unlike most other ideas put forth. I'd still call it an absolute long shot, and an even longer shot that such beings could leave their star.
A cat will see a book as a flat surface which probably smells of its owner and go to sleep on it. It has no other concept of "book." And if it sees an open book it can't see the contents as writing, because it has no concept of writing.
The fascinating part is that a human will see the same object but perceive it very differently because of the added human-specific knowledge and cognition.
Unless you're going to make the very bold claim that humans are the most sophisticated and advanced life in the universe, our perceptions will be limited in an analogous way.
We see clouds of dust and gas, star systems, and random background noise. An intelligence a few million years ahead of us may see the same objects as [symbol] and [relationship] in ways we literally can't imagine.
Probably in very similar ways, given how many ways there are to perceive something.
Ants, cats, and humans are all carbon-based lifeforms with eyes, nervous-systems, and brains.
Imagine how a cat perceives a bird vs. how a human perceives a bird vs. how a cloud of neutrons perceives a bird.
Children of Memory it is called.
Downloaded but not read yet!
While I find it unlikely that aliens have travelled to our solar system specifically to visit humans, I find it incredibly unlikely that human activity have not been detected by a Sentinel probe and that this probe has not relayed this info to its creators.
Radio waves have only been emitted for ~80 years. Industrialisation changing our atmosphere ~200 years. Even if something was persistently monitoring you are relying on “The creators” being within a short distance in light years to even have been notified.
Even being extremely optimistic about the speed of light not being absolute, other than wishful thinking - what makes you think that this scenario is “incredibly likely”?
The probes have arrived far before humans or even life existed on earth and have been waiting and watching ever since, with some of them possible reporting back to their creators on the state of earth while others still watching without yet sending a message because the state of earth hasn't reached some threshold.
As for if these signals have made it back to the probes' creators yet, I consider that unlikely due to the scale of the universe.
Once we can reliably detect and generate gravity waves much of our knowledge of electromagnetic waves can apply. 802.11gr anyone?
Now look into how you construct a soliton, and try to figure out what monstrous levels of control you'd have to exert over solar-system sized quantities of degenerate matter to create them, and how much energy it would take.
Now compute how much laser light you can generate for, oh, let's say, 6 orders of magnitude less energy. And how tightly you'd expect a civilization that apparently can casually wiggle dozens of solar masses at multiple Hz, in a modulated manner no less (so just a several Hz orbit is not sufficent, we are wiggling these things under power), to be able to collimate such a beam.
This is the problem with gravity waves. It isn't some sort of supreme cheat code of the universe for super awesome communication. It's transparently obviously idiotic. Like, not just, "well, it's not necessarily the best way, but even if it's not great someone may have tried it", like, you're burning dozens of orders of magnitude more energy per bit. Plural dozens, of orders of magnitude. Not dozens of times, ten to the power of dozens. This is not sensible no matter how advanced the civilization. We're talking levels of stupid that would greatly exceed spending the entire output of Earth's collective industrial civilization for all of history on a single pack of Skittles. This is not a bright thing to do, and it only gets dumber the smarter you suppose the aliens are.
Keep in mind, not too long ago we thought we needed to heat up a fillament surrounded by an inert gas in order to make artificial light, and our understanding of gravity is fairly poor (to the point where it's largely considered an unsolved problem quite how it fits together with other parts of physics).
We have no reason to assume gravity waves couldn't be produced artificially. This wouldn't really break any existing understandings of physics, it would merely require adding to them. The question is just how.
We do have reason to think that information can't travel faster than the speed of light, as this would make it possible to send information to the future and then back to the past via a closed time-like curve, which would have all manner of effects that contradict what we've observed about how the universe works, and in fact are self-contradictory as well. This doesn't go to say this isn't possible, after all the Alcubierre drive seems hypothetically possible (it "only" hinges upon the ability to create negative energy density), it's just much more implausible.
It’s not the possibility of communication with gravity waves that people are disputing, it’s that without as much science fiction as FTL the energy requirements are so massive that you completely negate the arguments against light for the same purpose.
Without this SF leap, you could just pour the energy into making a light as bright as e.g. a supernova and it would be multiple orders of magnitude cheaper and less difficult to generate the energy. This is completely ignoring the case where you know the direction you want to communicate with and build a laser.
Yes, you can come up with plausible sounding SF ideas about why you might want to do this but please don’t pretend that it’s grounded in anything tangible.
The assumption that there's some way to use gravity waves easily.
I can't prove that I can't generate gravity waves by the proper chanting of a spell. I'm serious, not just being silly. The simulation hypothesis certainly admits of such things being built into an otherwise sensible simulation (at the risk of a bit of a spoiler, https://qntm.org/ra ). If you want to talk about what could be if we bend what we understand this way, by all means, be my guest. I'm a big fan, actually.
However, I think we should be clear that we are doing that, and specify the rule changes we're considering.
In the real universe, we do "know" how to generate gravity waves. We can't do it at any sensible scale, but we know how. The energy computations are trivial extensions of Einsteinian relativity, suitable for assigning an undergraduate for homework.
Besides, the way of making gravity waves has to not just be like three or four times better than wiggling a neutron star, to beat light, it needs to be the aforementioned dozens of orders of magnitude better. Just like lasers, you'd be looking at the thing being a great weapon rather than just a communication mechanism. It's actually a lot of orders of magnitude improvement necessary. A fire on the end of a stick versus the brightest modern stadium lights don't even begin to cover the magnitude range.
People keep acting like light is some sort of terrible communication mechanism that we need to somehow level up from. The reality is that the only improvement you could practically ask of it is to go faster. It is otherwise unbelievably good at communication. It is hard to even conceive of what could be better in anything like our real universe.
I see no reason a sufficiently advanced species would choose gravitic waves over any other EM wave. Does someone with a clue (not me) have any ideas why this would be the case?
But yes, we've coordinated detections between LIGO and radar astronomy now, and there's no reason to believe gravity travels FTL. As always, there are error bars, but they're tight enough not to get excited about. That is, who cares if gravity travels at 1.00000000000001 the speed of light? (The theoreticians would go absolutely ballistic, but pragmatically that would mean nothing.)
Well except the part where you could use gravity waves to send messages to the past, I imagine that would have some pragmatic implications.
You can’t just break one postulate and assume the rest of the consequences are still ironclad.
That's... No, that's not what General Relativity says at all. The speed of light as universal speed limit is not a postulate, it is a result.
The reason is because going faster than light would break causality, as I mentioned, meaning time travel, and therefore meaning all kinds of paradoxes. That is why it is generally said that FTL travel is impossible; because the consequences of it being possible are absurd.
At least, that’s my lay understanding of it.
So, nothing specific to gravity waves allows for backwards time travel, so much as anything that carries information traveling FTL would cause backwards time travel.
I actually went down a fairly deep rabbit hole to try and get to why GR proponents believe > C travel allows for “breaking causality”.
It basically comes down to a box plot mechanism they have breaking down when FTL is used, and is absurd.
I’ve yet to see any evidence that FTL would break causality.
Something like a neutrino bean sounds more plausible as a communication medium than gravitational waves
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale#:~:text=equiva...
0.01 K1 was a generous overestimate. Strictly speaking, K1 really should be 2e17 W, putting us at .0001 K1.
(600 exajoules/y = 600,000,000 Tj/y, divided by 31.5M s/y = 19 TW. https://www.statista.com/statistics/265598/consumption-of-pr... )
K = (log10(P) - 6) / 10, where P is power in Watts.
20 TW = 2e13 W -> K = (log10(2e13) - 6) / 10 = ~(13.3 - 6) / 10 = ~0.73
Also, seems like you'd get a lot of collisions. Everybody in the universe broadcasting via gravity waves would be doing it on the same "frequency" (so to speak) right?
You'd also be perturbing the entire universe. Unlike radio waves, the gravity waves are going to have a very real effect on the objects through which they pass. If you're using gravity waves to communicate with somebody zillions of light years away, seems like you'd disrupt all the nearby star systems.