I have seen it done at a number of companies. The only two I ever saw it done correctly were a less than 50 people consulting firm I worked at called MCCI (led by a bona fide genius named Terry Moore), and third-hand at a statistical analysis firm called SAS (known for many best practices at the time).
Put another way: In theory this will work, in practice theory often doesn't.
What I have usually seen is some combination of:
* Workers are informally racked and stacked according to the time they take off
* Workers get pushed to meet deadlines and PTO necessary for physical health, mental health, or to meet family commitments is denied until the deadline is met
* Burnout rates increase
* Worker churn increases, due to the above
That said, Microsoft has innovated in a number of ways and seems to be a decent company to work for now (depending on the team), from what I hear from friends. I hope they implement this well, and it serves as a blueprint for others.
Because we should all be able to stay home and recover when sick (and not infect others), and we should all be able to take a mental health day when needed. There will be people who abuse it, but that will wind up fairly obvious and those people can be fired after sufficient documentation of poor performance.