Wisconsin governor bans TikTok from state devices on security concerns
reuters.com
reuters.com
I know that TikTok isn't strictly popular here on Hacker News or on Reddit, but the product is not appreciably different than Vine. The general public loves using TikTok, and this can be see from how it genuinely competes with Youtube in terms of user engagement.
On the other hand, the app hasn't been banned on consumer devices like it was in India. If the national security risk was genuine, I can't imagine the government would be this slow to act. Indian banned the App back in 2020. Some universities have also banned TikTok on their wifi networks.
I personally don't agree with the bans without public evidence of a cybersecruity threat. A company hoarding user data that users are willingly supplying doesn't become a cybersecurity risk just because that company is Chinese. The age group that is currently in college are the biggest users and creators of TikTok, they will use a VPN or switch to data to consume content. Until evidence is transparently release, showing nonconsensual data/OSINT gather, this feels like a political play. Especially since similar data gathering companies are not just allowed to exist, but employed by the US government for their intelligence gathering. Palantir is continuing work with the US government to create a surveillance state, more than what they did to help arrest and deport immigrants crossing the border.
I hope we see some information showing concrete secruity threats from TikTok.
Imo it often comes from people who dislike and don't use the app for whatever personal reasons, but it annoys them that there are people who find value in it. This is pure armchair psychologizing and shouldn't be taken seriously.
Disclaimer: I am absolutely the least likely person to agree with CCP on anything, and I am totally in support of the recently passed ban on Huawei equipment in the US infra (given the reasoning and evidence behind it was very solid).
The actual problem is the US establishment giving a pass to all of the US headquartered surveillance companies - presumably because they think of them as representing American "innovation" while being deluded into thinking that fine grained laws can be passed to reign them in later if it's "needed". (Just like what hasn't happened with Equifax, Experian, LexisNexis, etc)
Rather than political whinging about Tiktok, what we need is effective privacy legislation that neuters the power of every would be surveillance company - despite how the digital totalitarianism industry has become a shining star of the US economy.
It's important to make a distinction between a cybersecurity threat due to active exploits and attacks, and a privacy threat due to OSINT mining. I don't believe the second case, currently, justifies an outright ban. If the second also justifies a ban, then every single mainstream piece of software, from smart tv os, to social media, to phone apps, to laptop and desktop os, to entire governments, to even the DMV (for selling info) are should be banned.
In some of those cases, I'd argue they have already done worse than TikTok, the DMV currently sells personal infromation without your explicit consent to data brokers. The information the DMV sells access to includes, name, address, employment, voluneer organizations, and vehicle records to some of the same companies you metioned, LexisNexis and Experian. [1]
An interesting and alarming disclosure to me is WA DMV explicitly states "We provide data services for authorized recipients. For example: ... Research, such as an obesity study." You information can be used in a research study without your explicit consent. People are read open about sharing opinions on what they like publicly. I enjoy Harry Potter TikToks memes, I'm sure I've posted HP in my public Facebook likes back in the day, and I'm sure I've shared some book quotes on my twitter that's associated with my real identity. And now this post.
OSINT isn't just a part of the economy, it's also a part of the government. That's why this ban doesn't sit right with me.
You're trying to shoehorn this concern into whether or not it is a CFAA violation, which it is generally not. But privacy is orthogonal to unauthorized access - a healthcare provider can violate HIPAA even though they obtained your data legally. A comprehensive privacy law ala the EU's GDPR is the first legal step for pushing back against the massive abuse of data all of these companies shamelessly engage in.
And it is unfortunate that with the brokenness of our political system there would be many loopholes carved out of such a thing (like your DMV example, the longstanding financial surveillance bureaus, etc). But only by starting to draw a line in the sand can we possibly move towards a society with a meaningful concept of privacy, and repudiate the unaccountable totalitarian systems that Surveillance Valley has been building.
I agree that this particular ban seems like nothing but simplistic political grandstanding. But once again there is a much simpler universal rule that should already have been in place for state owned devices - a blanket prohibition of every app that isn't necessary for the job.
I am not sure why you believe the kind of security violation is shoehorning in an unnecessary concern. Technology and software should only be banned at a nation level when it is a threat to national security.
TikTok is a something people can uninstall at any time and people voluntarily choose to install. If you can't see the difference between someone sharing their interest in Harry Potter and the DMV selling your information, without your knowledge or consent, to predatory companies, then I don't think I can explain explain my perspective properly. I did not give the DMV height and weight (listed on the driver's license), my car accident history or insurance information or employment information to sell, they didn't ask before they did. When I travel to a different country, I did not consent to having my face scan taken by the TSA for facial recognition purposes. It's "optional" but that's not how it was presented when I travelled.
I am not sure what I am whitewashing, I make it clear that I expect there is evidence of TikTok exfiltrating data illegally. There is very little chance of the US sharing evidence publicly because that kind of accuastion could start retalitory cyberattacks. If that evidence was public, I would support the ban. But there's nothing public, and unlike with Huawei, there's no conditional evidence either. There's no evidence of TikTok being used to influence public opinion, there's nothing actionable that makes it different than any other social media site. The US Goverment not wanting China to have the data of their citizens isn't a national security threat, it's trying to avoid the consequencees of their intentionally bad policies regarding user privacy. Policies they exploit.
I remember that there was an issue with military personnel getting in trouble using fitness and walking tracking apps at secured bases. People started noticing random high density areas in the technically uninhabited places on maps, they turned out to be military bases. In that case the fitness tracking was banned due to national security issues, but obviously it wasn't malicious abuse of user data. It's not data that the fitness tracker obtained indirectly using data brokers, people voluntarily submitted the data.
There are two separate situations. People should avoid using TikTok because there is a question about whether China has unrestricted access to mine it. People should avoid social media because any kind of social media allows companies and governments to mine it. The separate issue is that there is unproven fears that TikTok is spying on users in some way for the benefit of the Chinese government. This is unproven. This kind of spying would be a genuine critical national security risk of the highest degree. The first and second situation aren't equivalent threats.
I recognize that we have different standard regarding what is severe enough to justify a ban. I hope I was able to demonstrate my perspective about why I think the ban is actually harmful with respect to users, because it lets the government avoid addressing the actual issue. It is a form of censorship, because as of now, it's only politically motivated. The ban wasn't because the government cares about user privacy. If the government really wanted to draw a line in the sand, they would start within the government itself.
Edit:
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/01/critics-find-fla...
I don't think most people realize how dangerous it would be to attack section 230 as a way to implement Europe style privacy laws. It's literally yet another attack on privacy. It seems like Biden is a fan of the old EARN IT bill. It will never pass in the US, but still makes me nervous.
> I am not sure why you believe the kind of security violation is shoehorning in an unnecessary concern
I am talking about privacy, and the need for general privacy legislation. Your response brushed that aside in favor of talking about "security violations", seemingly asserting that the only metric for analyzing privacy-hostile actions is whether they violate existing laws like the CFAA.
> difference between someone sharing their interest in Harry Potter and the DMV selling your information
The two dynamics are overwhelmingly similar:
You have "voluntarily" chosen to give your data to TikTok, and to the DMV. You wouldn't have chosen to give your information to either of them in isolation, but you were pushed into doing so as a condition of partaking in some other activity. At any time, you can choose to stop giving new information to either. However they both can continue using information you have already given them, and at any time both can come up with new ways of abusing your information and unilaterally alter the deal you originally signed up for.
Asserting a strong difference between the two is ultimately just buying into partisan propaganda that blesses the actions of government xor corporations. From where I'm standing, they're both mostly-unaccountable bureaucratic power structures that exercise coercive power. There are indeed differences, but on this issue not enough to be meaningful - large well-established surveillance companies have much more in common with government than they do with small businesses and individuals (which are at the opposite end of the spectrum).
> I don't think most people realize how dangerous it would be to attack section 230 as a way to implement Europe style privacy laws. It's literally yet another attack on privacy
There is a lot to unpack here. I do not see how an "EU style" privacy law can be considered an attack on privacy, apart from some weird framing where corporations should have the right to privately strip individuals of our privacy.
I'm no fan of EARN IT, and I think focusing on S230 is fallacious (the only interesting question there is the hypothetical of whether the lack of S230 would have prevented the surveillance industry from growing up like it did - perhaps with increased liability, the tech industry would have continued producing honest user-representing software rather than switching business models to being centralized media sites. But that ship has sailed long ago).
Rather, I am advocating for privacy laws on their own. A free society is not one comprised of numerous unaccountable surveillance databases. And to the extent that I do consent for a business to process my information in the course of providing a service, this should not give them the right to retain it indefinitely nor abuse it for their own purposes.
> makes me wonder what the NSA found out about TikTok.
Same thing they already know about Facebook, Google etc., except they have control over those. These are tools of mass control, better than any religion or pledge of allegiance.