Only paper ballots, with humans counting them, and humans observing them, can properly be "Proof of human": proof that there's an actual human being behind the vote. The fundamental problem in "Proof of human" is that fake identities are easily fabricated, dead humans can keep on voting if the government "forgets" about them, and finally, backdoors can be inserted into software systems creating a single point of failure, and the incentives of the government funding these systems is to get re-elected. Mail ballots, voting machines, and early voting where there are months of voting and volunteers don't have time to oversee months of voting, it's all problematic.
The fundamental measure in "Proof of human" is how many humans you need to trust to have confidence in the results. Do you need million election workers to go rogue? 100,000? 100? or maybe only 20 election workers in the right position can completely change the result? That's what makes the difference between fraud being a conspiracy and plausible: the number of people who need to be part of the conspiracy.
Getting a cryptographic backdoor in electronic voting systems is not even in conspiracy land, it requires only handful of people to be a part of it, and it can even happen remotely by an adversary country (such as Russia).