Ask HN: Got an email from someone expecting a bug bounty. What to do?
Bug = I didn't have DMARC set up for outgoing email verification.
I ignored their email, set up email monitoring. I knew I didn't have SPF verification set up, but had put it off.
A few weeks then nothing.
Then they emailed and said:
"Kindly update me regarding the issue and I am expecting a bug bounty from you for sending this bug ethically to you."
I ignored it.
A few more weeks later then I saw a bunch of spoofed emails sent from the domain in the email report.
I then setup DMARC for forensic reports.
Then a week or so later / now, they emailed and said:
"Alot of websites have rewarded me for letting them know about this bug because this is an impactful bug. It will be justifiable if you reward me in any way either a cash reward, amazon gift voucher or a swag as a token of appreciation. Also, i've found more critical bugs too so if you're willing to make your website safer you won't take this matter lightly."
What should I do?
It kinda seems like they're trying to threaten me.
If I give them a $10 or $25 Amazon gift card will this all go away or will they ask for more things? I'd be happy to give them something if it's small and they won't contact me again. But I don't want to open a can of worms and have them contact me again and again. I also don't want to ignore them and have them do something sketchy.
Anyone dealt with something similar?