Hacker News Reader

Comment by bluetomcat | Hacker News Reader

As of PHP 5, it lost its way and started imitating the Java OO model with a worse botched-on syntax. PHP 4 used to be a compact "hypertext preprocessor" with many built-in groups of functions, enabling you to process forms, talk to databases or process images without much code.

View on HN

How has PHP lost its way?

It grew up from a poorly thought out hacky scripting language to a major programming language. All the nasty code you could write in PHP 4 or 5 is still possible, but everyone will look at your code and laugh.

There are many other possible directions the language could have evolved in since then. For example, an emphasis on its dynamism and statelessness rather than introducing a static Java-like OO model for building hierarchies of classes. Or a modular system that encourages the user to put “complex” code in C modules, making application development as simple as calling a few functions.

Maybe because there are already major programming languages at that level already, which arguably do things better: if you are going to have a Java-like OO model, then just use Java (and leverage its ecosystem, tooling etc). Whereas there is a niche for a quick-and-dirty scripting language for just getting something up and running.

... You can still hacky script in it, my dude. I have to do that several times a year for stuff like one-off ETL's for customer data, or to verify an idea before rewriting it properly..

Absolutely nothing about modern PHP stops you from writing like the crayon-muncher you were back in the early 2000's...

You just also have the option, to, you know, use battle tested libraries and work with cohesive community driven standards now as well.

If you honestly think Java is the solution to replace PHP you clearly know very little about the language and its usage.

Poorly thought out?

Only the language that runs most of the internet and invented the term tight development loop.

All the modern crap has just moved us further away from this.

Those functions are all still there. You can still do <?php echo “Hello world!” ?> if you like.

<? mysql_connect(...) ?> isn't doing too well

If you wanna hang your hat on that, go for it. The hacky approach the parent poster yearns for is still entirely possible, even if you have to update a half-dozen lines of mysql_connect to mysqli_connect.

It's a pretty dumb argument to make on the basis that no functionality was lost (There is both the MySQLi extension, and the more general PDO one), and if you really, really can't get the budget to refactor it, you can drop a single shim file in to "get those functions back" while using either of the mentioned extensions to do the actual work.

mysql_connect has been heavily discouraged for at least 15 years now.

PHP 4.1 came out with mysqli in 2001. So you could argue that mysql_ functions have been bad practice for over 20.

This made me realize how ild I am :)

Weren't the 90s just 10 years ago?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com