I prefer to get my data about such things from cold research, not from "scientists" whose salaries come from fighting a cause.
I prefer to get my data about such things from cold research, not from "scientists" whose salaries come from fighting a cause.
The actual paper is legit:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2022.115165
The first author is from Duke University, the paper is peer-reviewed, and the journal 'Environmental Research' has an impact factor of 8.4 which is quite fair.
Also even if I look at the group who participated in the study, EWG, their mission seems to be focused on empowering consumers with information on environmental choices, which for an NGO seems fairly apolitical to me.
Furthermore you did nothing to impeach the credibility of their study.
You haven't really clarified why this is though. You've stated without backing it up with anything that
> EWG is an incredibly political organization that is not at all about empowering consumers, but rather in marshaling them for a cause, usually by convincing them that their local tap water is full of two-headed nuclear reactor fish.
In this case it happens to be their own research. But it's still normal and reasonable for them to make a press release about it, even if it's their own study.
I think the issue here, or your complaint rather, is based on the expectation that HN items would be more independent. Of course it's often not this way, as we see plenty of promotional pieces from tech companies posted here.
Regardless, all “scientists” are paid for results. Look at any research grant. The vast majority make several major assumptions. Anything environment related even more so. Good luck getting a grant proving prior climate science papers are bunk (most are). The established scientists are those giving out the grants, they won’t let you disprove their work.
Citation needed.