Uses and abuses of military history
newcriterion.com
newcriterion.com
"Secondly, racial tensions between white and black soldiers and marines increased after the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. in April 1968."
From TFA:
"At about the same time, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin testified before Congress, promising to root from the armed forces supposed cadres of white supremacists driven by “white rage.” Yet neither he nor Gen. Milley ever supplied data or evidence that such cells or movements exist in the U.S. military.
That the Pentagon should foster such ungrounded suspicions of white males—one of its most important sources of recruits—is as if the British war ministers had questioned whether there were too many sexist British Gurkhas in the ranks, or Russian generals had wondered whether there were Cossacks that seemed clannish, or the Indian government had fixated on Sikh recruits as religious chauvinists.
Implying that white males collectively are intrinsically suspect of improper behavior seems a near-suicidal U.S. Army policy, given that the group died at a rate double its percentages in the general population in both Afghanistan and Iraq."
OK, so the brass didn't cite their sources. This doesn't mean such don't exist, and likewise recognizing the very real problem of fascist/far-right white supremacists in the military is not the same thing as "Implying that white males are intrinsically suspect".
Here's a link that indicates the military has a real problem with fascist infiltration, from the horse's mouth, as it were:
https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2021/01/14/...
"Though the services do background checks for extremist views and will drop recruiting prospects when they find evidence of it, the armed forces has a particular challenge when it comes to extremist groups.
In short, there are aspects of military service “that are of appeal to these groups,” the official said.
“We know that some groups actively attempt to recruit our personnel into their cause, or actually encourage their members to join the military for [the] purpose of acquiring skills and experience,” the official added."
> Russian generals had wondered whether there were Cossacks that seemed clannish
The Russian military is extremely concerned with political loyalty, and extremely, violently, "anti-woke". That's part of why they're losing. It's also noticeable that how ethnic-Russian a unit is determines how suicidal a position they are given.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/emily-rainey-fort-bragg-captain...
https://www.npr.org/2021/01/15/956896923/police-officers-acr...
Military analogy: If you are obsessed with soldiers named "Smith", "Jones", and "Wilson" in your unit taking 20% casualties from enemy artillery fire, but not overly concerned with the other soldiers also taking 20% casualties from that fire...maybe the armed forces would be better off without your "service".
I’m sorry but I cannot take seriously an article related to military history that uses meaningless words such as woke un-ironically.
An endless war that maimed and killed thousands of troops in Afghanistan that ended up being for literally zero reason.
There’s an entire world of history in the Second World War, but all too often we scratch the surface, with an eye focused entirely on the US and Western Europe.
Shocking that it ended up on the front page of HN
Cynically, you could say that the field attracts (and keeps) those interested in history who either want to ignore social and cultural elements of historical events, or want to explicitly advocate for specific societies and cultures being superior based on their record in the field of battle. It does not help that much of the field is driven by popular history books which must be engaging for lay readers, yet the truly important parts of many military operations are often quite boring (e.g. the essential role of logistics and basic day-to-day intelligence work) or remain unknown to this day (e.g. still classified, or simply weren't documented in the first place).