When markets crash you see more redemptions from bad funds than good funds; by only observing redemptions the good are ignored and bad are counted. Since those funds are still charging asset fees, the numbers are probably distorted towards 100% the worse the preceding period's equity market performance.
Are hedge fund structures in need of reform? Probably. Do we need to warp and mis-represent statistics to accomplish this? No.
Bottom line is that saying that the ratio of cash out to operators to cash out gross is 84% is meaningless given that it has survival bias built in - in the inverse. Bad funds who dissolve and result in massive outflows are over-represented. Those that succeed and hold capital, e.g. Berlshire Hathaway and Renaissance'a Medallion Fund, are ignored.
I'm just imploring the HN community to remain objective, even when bad evidence seems to agree with our pre-conceived notions.