How fast can it be regulated up and down? We need solutions to step in when neither wind is blowing nor sun is shining.
How fast can it be regulated up and down? We need solutions to step in when neither wind is blowing nor sun is shining.
Nuclear waste is in general mostly a solved problem. A bunch of barrels less or more over the lifecycle of the plant in the storage site does not move a needle much, economically or otherwise.
Initial investment dominates the equation. It mostly does not make sense to ramp nuclear power up and down, because of economical reasons. Gas costs are mostly dominatd by the fuel, so there ramping up and down makes sense. Nuclear costs are dominated by the initial investment.
But even without ramping up and down, still nuclear power helps integrate variable renewables, since it is providing valuable inertia to keep the grid stable.
Storage of nuclear waste was one of several issues that led residents around the Indian Point nuclear plant to push hard for its shutdown, at which they eventually succeeded.
Other issues included ecological harm to the adjacent Hudson River due to discharge of unnaturally warm water, and (probably the biggest one) the risk of widespread death and injury in the event of an accident or terrorist attack.
Indian Point is in relatively densely populated area with relatively low-capacity highways, and there was a pervasive sense that the official evacuation plans would be insufficient in case of a disaster.
If the plan here is to make more, smaller, cheaper nuclear plants in or near more cities and towns, this means you are going to have even more towns putting up the same local resistance on those same issues. Advocates of nuclear will need to have answers.
Not really. Nobody ever wants power generation in their backyard. Doesn't matter if it's dangerous nuclear or polluting fossil fuel or eye-sore wind. The answer is always one of the same two options: do it anyway, or put it in someone else's backyard.
Resistance is a matter of proportion and intensity. A few assholes will complain about wind. A lot of people remember Three Mile Island and Chernobyl, and wouldn't care about an eyesore wind farm but would worry about the effects of an accident at a nuclear plant.
You are basically saying that NIMBYs exist and therefore nobody's complaints about nuclear power are valid. Good luck with that attitude.
Every option has downsides. Every proposal faces opposition. Every project is decided individually.
The nuclear advocates don't need a special extra requirement to convince everyone in the world to choose nuclear. They're going to go through the same process as everyone else every time.
I said something neutral about nuclear and you invented a personal attack on yourself and reprimanded me for it. Good luck with that attitude, I guess?
This is what I responded to. It sounds pretty absolute to me.
That's the same part where I validated other concerns. Wtf is wrong with you
Solar power plants produce zero waste, and those are opposed:
* https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/oct/30/its-got-...
* https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-solar-expansion-stalled-...
Wind farms create no waste, and are also opposed:
* https://www.npr.org/2022/03/28/1086790531/renewable-energy-p...
Seems like people are just opposed to building anything around them, waste or not.
So, ah, where are those "few" barrels getting stored?
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/12/18/nuclear-waste-why-theres-no-...
Only a few countries (e.g. Finland) have permanent storage underground for nuclear waste. But that was only opened fairly recently. France actually used to just dump it in the ocean. These days they are a bit more responsible. I think they are building a storage facility that is supposed to open some time next decade. Meanwhile, just like in most other places, they just store the waste in sealed containers and store those on site.
I would say it's a solvable problem but not a solved problem. The solution has a large price tag with absolutely no return on investment. And that's a problem that doesn't have any solution.
It's mostly solved - solved for most of the waste material, just not for a few bits which, dag nab it, seem to radiate out of those barrels.
All this is because absolute cost is not much affected by whether it is producing.