It’s so hard to talk about this without being labelled a “vaccine denier”.
We all knew the initially claimed protection rates were overstated, it was acknowledged as a limitation in the initial study protocol but ignored by politicians and media.
For the validation trials, due to the time / resource requirements (we didn’t have PCR capacity) testing for seroconversion/positivity was only done on symptomatic patients and not at a routine time interval. This type of testing is well known to result in overestimating treatment effects (you’re missing all the people who didn’t self declare symptoms and get tested by not having strictly adhered testing intervals) and there’s zero doubt “94% protection” was an overestimate (even by the original Pfizer study authors). By how much, we’re not sure, and we absolutely needed something in a time of uncertainty and it was the right decision at the time given available resources and pandemic pressures.
As evidence has accumulated, we’re realizing the vaccine effects and COVID mortality (particularly post Delta) are vastly overstated.
I have not seen a CT chest with the “cardboard lung” appearance of COVID-19 pneumonia or ECMO patients since December/Jan 2022, and I was reporting inpatient chest imaging in the largest ECMO center in Ontario at multiple points during the pandemic.
The “sniff test”, suggested things were changing (like population drift with a ML model). And the issue with the vaccine rollout is we went back to “science based medicine” rather than the currently accept “evidence based medicine” where lab tests like neutralization assays were being extrapolated into clinical outcomes. Medicine moved away from this type of reasoning for a reason, you really need to look at higher level outcomes to know what’s actually going on. You can rationalize many treatments on a scientific level (as was done for anti malarial drugs at some point) but it usually ends up invalid.
What’s being proven true now, is that we overestimated both COVID mortality due to confounding effects of co-admission (how many inpatients are there BECAUSE of COVID not with it) as well as the effectiveness of vaccines, particularly at later stages in the pandemic. They probably worked well for COVID 1.0 up to Delta at preventing serious illness but that quickly dropped.
I don’t buy the evidence to support current vaccination recommendations with the bivalent (esp. young and healthy), and you can see many institutions have dropped that requirement (only the initial 2 dose series was ever mandatory at my place)