I have a lot to say about "ill defined and broad", starting with "I agree with you" and followed immediately by "c'est la vie". In a nutshell: we are extremely limited in how much time we can ask of candidates: our budget is the typical amount of time we believe those candidates would spend in more typical interview process (phone screens and an on-site interview loop). That means our programming work samples (WSTs) are small, which means we have to take every opportunity to extract signal from them, which in turn limits exactly how much we can document about our expectations.
We try to be clear in our assessments (and to give some feedback about our decisions). I feel like we do a better-than-average job of being transparent, responsive, and fair, but I would feel that way: I'm the Retail Sales Manager.