Synchronous Observation of Bell Nonlocality and State-Dependent Contextuality
journals.aps.org
journals.aps.org
What does this mean? Wouldn't this be expected? Why wouldn't previous results have demonstrated this?
Quantum mechanics says you can't measure arbitrary observables simultaneously, so you can only choose two out of five rather than the whole set of five.
A previous work combined the nonlocality and contextuality setup and showed that you couldn't detect the contextuality on one particle and the nonlocality between the two particles simultaneously. However the previous work assumed you only use the results of one of the two contextuality measurements you do as part of your nonlocality detection. I.e. the previous work had both measurements on particle A being used to detect contextuality, and used the results of one of those combined with the results of a measurement on particle B to detect nonlocality.
In this work they show that if you lift this assumption, so the nonlocality is now being detected by both measurements on A as well as the measurement on B, you can detect the nonlocality and contextuality simultaneously.
Which makes me think that Bell was right that Bohmian mechanics places the real problem with QM, non-locality, front and centre where it can't be ignored.
The reason this has more relevance for Bohmian mechanics is because that interpretation makes the non-locality explicitly manifest in the core ontology, where other interpretations try to eliminate the non-locality via other means, eg. Copenhagen eliminates counterfactual definiteness, many worlds eliminates collapse, etc.
Edit: This means Bohmian mechanics has an unresolved tension with relativity, which is why it hasn't yet been extended to a field theory.
Quantum nonlocality is perfectly compatible with special relativity. The spacetime of the standard model of particle physics is exactly the flat spacetime of special relativity.
Far from being ignored, the compatibility between special relativity and quantum mechanics has been investigated and demonstrated experimentally over the past century.
In modern graduate courses this is best seen by studying the relevant group theory.
You can read more about the SO(3,1)+ Lorentz group (which also applies to the Maxwell-Heaviside field equations for electromagnetism and the Dirac equation) at e.g. <https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/Representation_theory_of_the...>.
These are also excellent lecture notes: <https://arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0602018> and <https://www.ippp.dur.ac.uk/~krauss/Lectures/StandardModel/St...>
...if you accept the ontology of certain interpretations of QM. Bohmian mechanics is based on a different ontology, which is why Bohmian mechanics currently has to posit a preferred foliation of spacetime in order to square with relativity. This is a little ugly, to put it mildly.
Edit: and the point I was making re:non-locality being the real problem, is because there are still plenty of unresolved issues between QM and general relativity, and I think these will come down to ontological incompatibilities, and so a different ontology may provide the insight needed to make a breakthrough.
The problems between general relativity and quantum mechanics are not at this subtle interpretational layer. They're actual calculations you do, predictions you make, where the results you get make no sense.
In any case if the nonlocality of quantum mechanics was the problem then we should see issues already when trying to connect special relativity with quantum theory, and that seems to work pretty well (e.g. quantum electrodynamics seems fairly legit).
If you want to write, "therefore special relativity is wrong", then do so, and we'll have a lot less to talk about given how well-supported special relativity is by direct in-solar-system evidence.
In a previous edit up-thread you added that [de Broglie]-Bohmian mechanics has not been turned into a field theory. Incorrect. It is easy to do turn it into a field theory, but that field theory will not be relativistic. One can add extra structure on the spacetime of special relativity and get a quasi-relativistic field theory. As you note in your second paragraph above, one can do this by picking out a universally true time axis and demoting the infinity of others to pseudo-time.
However, in "Can Bohmian mechanics be made relativistic?" <https://arxiv.org/abs/1307.1714v2> the authors take seriously the idea that the distribution of matter (and its dynamics) picks out a particular foliation.
As a relativist this doesn't bother me: the distribution of matter at cosmological scales (i.e., ignoring "local stuff" it's effectively homogeneous and isotropic from all vantage points) and its dynamics picks out the cosmological frame, after all, and we use that to talk about things happening billions of years ago. However, it's hard to grind this kind of matter-picks-out-a-frame thinking down to the scale of a terrestrial particle-collider experiment or to natural astrophysical "experiments" like magnetars. (The second-last paragraph of the Discussion section of the paper is provocative, however.)
Also, I am cautious about predicting whether one can successfully "comma-goes-to-semicolon" a possibly-relativistic frame into a properly covariant theory. Often attempting to do so shows that one has what one might roughly call a surplus of long-distance forces that vanish only in the possibly-relativistic frame (or some family of related frames) but can be made incredibly strong in some other frame (or set of families of frames). The authors above are similarly cautious, and cannot answer their own question.
Finally,
> general relativity
if you are incompatible with special relativity at every point then you are also automatically incompatible with general relativity, because that guarantees SO(3,1)+ at every point and in its ultra-local neighbourhood even if you abolish it as a global symmetry. So your qualification of "relativity" as "general relativity" is unhelpful; SR, after all, just a special case of general relativity which is much closer to everywhere in the solar system than anything with strong enough curvature to make a difference in a beta- decay or relativistically smashing together two lead nuclei.
I'm aware of the paper you linked. As with all other attempts, it hasn't really gone anywhere.
There's nothing else from your comment I seriously disagree with, and it's not clear what, exactly, is your issue with how I've framed the problem. It's clear that orthodox QM posits a formal model that lets you make certain derivations that are compatible with relativity, and those derivations contain steps that are not compatible with Bohmian mechanics because of the latter's ontology.
I'm positing:
1. that those steps merely kick the can down the road, leaving certain irreconcilable differences between relativity and QM that we're still dealing with.
2. that Bohmian mechanics puts this problem front and centre, and if it can be overcome, it will provide unique insight into how to solve those issues in other interpretations.
It's kind of like how classical logic permits the excluded middle in a proof, where intuitionistic logic does not. Using the law of the excluded middle is a useful shortcut to truth, but it does not yield a path to a construction of the object in question. Explicit constructions are considerably richer in properties and so provide considerably more insight.
Orthodox QM excludes many details of what's going on, sort of like a proof depending on the law of the excluded middle, where Bohmian mechanics makes everything explicit and manifest, sort of like a construction in an intuitionistic proof. It seems very plausible that the richer construction will be more difficult to reconcile with a different formal model, but it also will yield considerably more insight if it can be done.
> I'm genuinely confused about what we're disagreeing on.
That our universe is locally Lorentz-invariant everywhere.
> I think this is a perfectly reasonable interpretation of my original claim that Bohmian mechanics doesn't have a field theory.
I don't, however charitably I am willing to read this as "Bohmian mechanics doesn't have a relativistic field theory" given the new material in your latest comment. "Relativistic" means that there is a Lorentzian manifold involved, either directly or as emergent property of the configuration space.
> front and center
No, what puts Lorentz-invariance front and centre in this context is the Standard Model Extension <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard-Model_Extension> which can carry the parameters for a de Broglie-Bohm pseudo-relativistic field theory which has additional Lorentz-invariance-violating (LIV) structure. Tests of such parameterized theories have all failed unless the controlling coefficients are designed to vanish beneath the floor of current-technology testability (in which case is the more complicated theory useful?).
There is no evidence at all for LIV physics in direct tests in multiple locations in our solar system, in observational tests within our solar system, or beyond it. Lorentz-invariance is probably the strongest-tested aspect of modern physics, as it forms part of any test of the standard model of particle physics, quantum electrodynamics, or general relativity. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_searches_for_Lorentz_vi...>
> irreconcilable differences between relativity and QM
There are no such differences between special relativity and relativistic QM, nor can there be because of the design of the latter type of theory. So you must be arguing that quantum mechanics is not special-relativistic. OK, more on that below.
The only thing that general relativity brings to the table is that global Lorentz-invariance becomes local Lorentz-invariance ("local" can be an arbitrarily large finite region, however) becomes ultralocal Lorentz-invariance in strong curvature, as in the radius of curvature is much less than the characteristic lengths in quantum chromodynamics (e.g., the available free-fall trajectories lead to spaghettification which ought to produce hadronization of the tidally-disrupted QGP or colour string, where the resulting hadrons are then themselves subject to tidal disruption; for a slowly-spinning black hole we're interested in the axial stress as the Weyl tensor deforms sphere->lengthening American football, one end pointing in, one pointing out->lengthening thin tube with slightly fatter middle than ends->...).
Since in GR strong curvature is hidden within various types of horizons there is no need to worry about proving ultralocal Lorentz-invariance, rather than proving e.g. the existence and behaviour of horizons (which are more readily testable features of GR). Maybe someday we'll watch a black hole fully under our control evaporate completely; or be able to induce extreme angular momentum and/or electric charge on a black hole we control. Until then, all we can do is speculate that either Lorentz-invariance holds up even in black holes and during the hot big bang, or the LIV in those regions washes out of our present-day observability through some unknown process.
> if it can be overcome
Well, right, you seem to be claiming that the universe is not locally Lorentz-invariant at every point. That is, that the universe is not relativistic. Fine, that's a claim which has been made before, and it is almost always a physically testable claim. Now try to prove it, like the other claimants. It may take considerable effort to do so in some "ontologically pure" way, but that's on you and anyone you convince to collaborate with you in this programme of research.
I promise that any serious effort would be taken seriously by at least some relativists. If nothing else, they would show you how to cast your attempted proof into a more standard test theory, and in particular how the test theory's coefficients relate to your proposal, and how they can be compared to experiment and observation.
(Clever people like Clifford Will do this in gravitation with some regularity <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternatives_to_general_relati...>. There are numerous parametrized test theories of a range of aspects of the Standard Model and BSM particle physics, too.)
https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.05385
just search for the paper name with the word arxiv after it on your favourite search engine and you'll find it 99% of the time. Usually when they get published in a real journal the arxiv version is updated to match the published version as well.
But they are vague about the implications and I'm generally unsure about the practical relevance of quantum protocols like superdense coding ...
Other quantum protocols are much more likely to be useful, perhaps particularly for cryptography.
Both of these require spending entanglement, so it’s not a very useful heuristic.
How do you do this?
(it goes against my intuition of a qubit as state in a hilbert space)
Yes one needs entanglement.
https://qiskit.org/textbook/ch-algorithms/teleportation.html
The Bell basis measurement has four outcomes. For convenience you can label them
00 01 10 11
Alice tells Bob the measurement outcome she got (this is the part that requires two bits of classical communication), and depending on which outcome she got Bob has to apply either no correction or a Pauli X, Y or Z gate.
This is known as quantum teleportation
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation
and has quite a long history at this point (proposed in the early '90s and first performed in the late '90s).
The summary is that you can only send messages ftl using quantum theory if you already know a way to send messages ftl without using quantum theory.