But yes, that is exactly what Hindenburg does – not sure if GC thinks shorting companies you think are frauds is a bad thing or what – as far as I'm concerned it is the best reason for shorts to exist! I'd have more questions if Hindenburg wasn't shorting Adani Group after this report.
Not only was he a highly successful field marshal on the Eastern Front in WWI (after being brought out of retirement to replace the panicking previous commander there), he later became de facto dictator of Germany for the remainder of the war (until it was time to surrender, then he threw the dumpster fire over the wall to the civilian politicians). (Of course as his second, Ludendorff, wouldn't miss to tell anyone after the war, Hindenburg's role was more one of moral authority, calming presence and coordination, the actual war plans being made by the people under him, most notably Ludendorff who was really pissed after the war Hindenburg took all the credit).
However he's even more interesting after WW1, when his popularity brings him to being elected as President, being in de facto control of Germany again thanks to a constitutional workaround, and then working to stop Hitler from getting to power before finally being convinced to give him the chancellorship. After his death, Hitler also took over the presidentship, and that was that. So Hindenburg was the only man who could stop/delay Hitler from taking power, and he failed.
(It's a less great thing that fraud of this sort is possible, and that falsely accusing others of fraud can happen too)
While such firms certainly have an incentive to make the company they've shorted look bad, it turns out that it works best (and is easier) when the company they short actually is bad. Thus, they've found a way to make a business out of identifying frothy financial bubbles built on shaky-to-fraudulent fundamentals and popping them.
It's kind of a public service in the sense that it corrects the market when it goes awry and ultimately they are betting their own money that their investigation is correct.
Haven't seen many "manufactured fraud" allegations. In my experience the research is often quite in-depth and they tend to be proven correct in the end.
But for instance in the case of "there's a new plague and China is locking down" there were several months between first hearing about it and everyone recognizing it.
If the report is true, there maybe insufficient market capacity for the stock to move freely, any short position - including the one that Hindenburg made maybe blown up by determined opposition.