The reason I suspect people don’t think scrolling was ever an issue (especially on iOS, I doubt Androids will share the same view), is because Apple spent so much time getting it right for the original iPhone. Correctly identifying that scroll behaviour was a kind of “killer app” for touch screens.
But in order to make that scroll behaviour so rock solid. They heavily constrained the problem and did bunch of visual tricks to make it appear smoother that it actually was. Most notably, native scroll views generally required that every individual scroll element was an identical size and shape. So you could cheat during the scrolling process by not actually rendering all the content while scrolling, just rendering the UI chrome (which was identical for every scroll item), and loading the content once the scroll velocity was low enough that there was time to load and render the details before they needed to be displayed.
The other thing that happened, was basically stopping any other compute from occurring. When you scrolled on the original iPhone (and for many generations afterwards), your phone basically dropped everything and dedicated all its compute to just scrolling the view. Not even code to compute the content of scroll elements was executed, you were expected to have done that before the scrolling started. This was most obvious in Safari, where JS execution was halted, and even page rendering was halted, so if you scrolled beyond the boundaries of what had already been rendered, you just got white.
With modern frameworks (and especially the web) there’s been a strong desire to deliver scrolling with a completely arbitrary set of scroll elements, that can all be different shapes, sizes, colours and trigger all manner of background computation. Modern devices are broadly capable of delivering that, but care is needed to exceed the available compute. That’s different from historical native frameworks, where they simply didn’t let people have that kind of flexibility. You got the handful of options the framework gave, and that’s it (which is why older iOS app all had identical scroll UI).
UiScrollView has always been harder to deal with.
So no, it’s never been a solved problem just like UI abstractions have never been a solved problem, so solved that there’s nothing to improve or explore.
Also keep in mind that the battery drain using those technologies to play a game does not scale to a normal mobile app when people expect their phone to be available all day.
Scrolling on the other hand is a very sequential task, if you don’t want to have a loading screen before displaying the list. The location of every item in the list depends on the location and size of the item before it, those data dependencies make parallelism pretty close to impossible. Made worse when each item is loaded on demand, and needs to execute code to determine how it should be rendered.
Of course, you could load all your scroll data into memory, precompute all the needed render parameters, arrange the results for parallel rendering, then have blazing fast and stable scrolling. Just like a video game loading screen, but then every scrollable view would have a loading screen…
It is not a big ask to have a scrolling UI. Look at motif from 80s.
It is a solved problem, the solution is load things lazily as needed, and the UITableViewDataSource protocol is one template you can follow for doing that.
> using UIKit...you use an api that recycles UI components to support lazy loading
They eventually added enough optimizations and performance cutouts to make it pretty easy to not fall in the hole with your app, so it hasn't been a problem with AppKit (or its younger 85% clone, UIKit) for a long while.
But I'm not surprised to hear Apple's much newer and not-very-related UI toolkit still has lots of those problems. That's one of the problems when not many developers actually use a technology — it's not just a popularity contest, having lots of users who complain is how you find a lot of the bugs and performance issues in your UI toolkits and app frameworks.
So lack of popularity often does mean there are probably a lot of those.