As an example, let’s take a homeowner who rents their old house to someone when they purchase a second home. The question is, what value are they providing to the renter to justify the huge cost? The rent payment must cover the mortgage payment and maintenance or else the landlord would be loosing money. The landlord essentially ends up with a free house, while the renter ends up loosing many tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars, and at the end of the lease, they have nothing.
The only value the landlord provided was happening to own an asset that’s in huge demand. If that asset was abundant, the renter would very likely be able to buy their own and be much better off.
Rent-seeking behavior (which is drastically incentivized when houses are such a valuable asset) is pretty much only a negative for society for two reasons:
1. It makes many people poorer without any equity to show for their huge financial commitment.
2. It makes housing more expensive, which also makes people poorer.
3. A poorer society means people have less money to spend on products that someone actually put in work/effort to produce.
The basic idea is that a landlord is generally not producing a product or putting in any meaningful effort. (The actual work is contracted out and paid for by rent.) They’re just profiting off of an asset they got lucky / rich enough to own —- which by itself isn’t that much of a problem, except housing is a basic human necessity/right.
So why shouldn’t society be profiting off of the asset’s (land’s) value?
But this line of thinking means you have to turn off that “capitalist greed” mindset that everyone gets by default.