An over-reaction to be sure… I expect no less from modern US laws enforcement.
An over-reaction to be sure… I expect no less from modern US laws enforcement.
People usually confuse the terrorist watch list with the no-fly list. The former being a list of persons known to having some involvement in terror activities in groups designated as terrorist groups by the US State Department.
The No-Fly list is generally full of criminals, unruly passengers, and people who have gotten violent on flights with crew or other passengers. It is also imperfect, with false positives occurring with people who have the same name as another listee.
It should be noted that the US government may not use the No Fly List to prevent U.S. citizens or permanent residents from returning home to U.S. territory, since doing so is a violation of the 14th amendment.
I was added to a watch list long ago that results in me being tossed in a cell and "detained" for up to 24 hours every time I go through customs but they always make it exceedingly clear I'm not under arrest (granted while sitting in immigration holding cell it doesn't feel much different).
It really gets annoying just being told by CBP "you know what's next" while never being able to find out what list you've been put on. I hope more of these lists become public.
The terrorist "watch-list" is a database of people that the US government considers at-risk of committing acts of terrorism. Whether you believe that is another story.
The no-fly list is a subset of the terrorism watch list. Criminals, unruly passengers, and violent offenders are specifically NOT on the no-fly list unless they're also on the terrorism watch list[0].
Unruly passengers are sometimes added to a no-fly list for a specific airline, but there is no national no-fly list that private companies are eligible to add to[1], and despite being charged federally with a crime in the air, you are not eligible to be added to the no-fly list for that reason.
[0] https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/terrorism/tsc
[1] https://news.delta.com/delta-ceo-ed-bastian-why-we-need-nati...
If this is a subset of the "terrorist watch-list", then that terrorist watch list must have even more names on it? I think you're implying many more? 5 million? 10 million? People that the US government "considers at-risk of committing acts of terrorism," really?
There are, what, a couple dozen acts of terrorism a year? (I don't know whether we're talking about in the US or globally or what). But millions of people the US government "reasonably" considers at risk to commit them? This seems... odd, no?
I don't think we knew how many people were on it before. But if it's a strict superset of the no-fly list, then we now know it's at least 1.5 million people.
I guess the only odd thing is that a lot of people seem to believe the USA government's line that more than 1.5 million people are "reasonably suspected to be involved in terrorism or related activities", when there are maybe a few dozen terrorist attacks a year. ("reasonably"! "related activities" huh?).
Its really not that hard to imagine the US gov. adding every person from the middle east that has ever flown in a plane to that list.
It's likely (though conjecture) the "lists" you are on, really the buckets you are in, are used as an input to some sort of "is a terrorist" qualifier, which sorts certain people into a priority queue to be tasked to other NSA agents to look into your details and pass you off to someone else if you seem sus, basically like companies that sell credit card fraud prevention.
Or you know, some sort of score that represents your social, let's call it "credit". Except you aren't allowed to request this score once a year.
> In fact, the vast majority of people who have disputed travel and appeal to the Department of Homeland Security’s Traveler Redress Inquiry Program are not on the terrorist watchlist.
> Most people on the terrorist watchlist are still able to fly within the U.S. A very small subset of people on this list are on the “No Fly” list.
Wow, so 1.5 million on the no fly list are a "very small subset" of (also from that page) "people reasonably suspected to be involved in terrorism (or related activities)", who have met "specific intelligence-related criteria", and which "Internal and external auditors regularly review... to ensure all laws and policies are being followed and that the information on the watchlist is accurate."
If 1.5 million people is a "very small subset", the whole list is... 10 million? 50 million? 100 million?
Something definitely ain't right.
I wonder if this clue as to the size of these lists can help organize some opposition, because it seems to indicate things are not what they say.