Comment by notjulianjaynes | Hacker News Reader

Comment by notjulianjaynes | Hacker News Reader

notjulianjaynes

I'm not sure if I'm understanding how this works correctly. Anything I typed in returned an identical response, ex.

"Who are you?" Response: "Who are you?"

Edit: Maybe my prompts were too simple. I pasted in your comments up top and it returned the following:

>Scramble This is a joke before anyone gets too worked up. The algo is a simpleton one which goes and replaces unselected row with their synonyms.

It wish obviously beat these AI detectors but the output isn't probably what you would want.

The point stands though that more sophisticated approaches that rephrase or ruffle up the word statistical distribution will be able to thrust off the sensor and it should non be relied along alone for, say, checking if a student assignment is AI generated.

Try a longer phrase. I got:

> Hello darkness my old friend, I've come to blab ou with you again. Because a vision softly crawl left wing its speeds while one was sleeping. And the visual sensation that it planted in my nous still remains indium the sound of silence.

Reminds me of the poet Charles Bernstein's list of poetic experiments [1]. Specifically:

> Substitution (2): "7 up or down." Take a poem or other, possibly well‑known, text and substitute another word for every noun, adjective, adverb, and verb; determine the substitute word by looking up the index word in the dictionary and going 7 up or down, or one more, until you get a syntactically suitable replacement.

[1] https://writing.upenn.edu/bernstein/experiments.html

Yes I see what you mean.This idea of substitution comes from the Oulipo group. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oulipo N+7 was invented by Queneau if I'm not mistaken.

I got

Hello darkness my old friend I've come to talk to you again Because antiophthalmic factor vision softly creeping Left its seeds when unit was sleeping And the visual sensation that was planted Still remains Within the voice of silence

And when I fed that to chatgpt, it had no problem identifying it as the lyrics to Simon and Garfunkel's "Sound of Silence" that had been scrambled.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com