We don't seem to even be trying to do this and it's depressing.
We don't seem to even be trying to do this and it's depressing.
- Make it door to door, no connections, no hiking to or from a station/stop/port at either end
- Make it on demand, no timetables or shortages
- Make it actually show up, and not be susceptible to strikes or moderately bad weather
- Make a ticket cost the same as or less than the cost in petrol (or electricity) for the same journey
- Make it private, without the need to be crammed into a box with strangers
These aren't unreasonable requirements, or some utopia situation. They're all things that personal cars provide that trains, planes, taxis, subways, and busses frequently (perhaps generally?) do not. I don't even commute, I work entirely remotely, and your proposal would still be a massive decrease in my quality of life whether it achieved your objective or not.
If you want alternatives to be more popular, make them better than the status quo for every individual rather than just waving at "the world in general" and saying it's better for that/them.
- They should not be stuck in traffic jams
- They should not kill children, pedestrians and cyclists
- They should be electric without heavy and polluting batteries
These aren't unreasonable requirements, or some utopia situation. They're all things that trains and subways provide that cars do not.
> - Make a ticket cost the same as or less than the cost in petrol (or electricity) for the same journey
In your utopia, do I get a free car and only spend money on petrol for travel? It it a country that provides free car repairs and service, need no insurance, MOT checks, and has no road tax?
In Britain the fixed costs of owning a car exceed £2000 a year before you've driven a single mile.
> They're all things that trains and subways provide that cars do not.
Figure out how to get trains to operate everywhere instead of only on fixed routes, and then this comparison will be valid. Until then you're talking about two (more, really) different use cases with a minimal amount of overlap.
So at the very least we will need buses, and a lot of them, to feed the areas where it't uneconomical or otherwise unfeasible to run rails. Do the environmental math on that -- how full does a bus need to be before the pollution per passenger is better than a compact car with one passenger? How about a compact car with four passengers? Public transit would need a fundamental change in approach.
And of course this is only talking about people. Always lost in this conversation is that moving humans from place to place is just one use case.
Sure, to some extent. The knowledge we already have about how to prevent e.g. cars killing children, pedestrians, and cyclists is that you slow them down (and separate them which also typically involves taking space from cars to make room). But as seen above in this thread, that kind of thing meets opposition from people who say you're "making good things in life shittier".
> the areas where it't uneconomical or otherwise unfeasible to run rails.
If you've never done this, I suggest taking a look at old maps of the US's passenger rail network. We had a lot more rail in the past than we do now.
Smaller roads with fewer lanes and lower speeds are very unpopular among car enthusiasts.
> Figure out how to get trains to operate everywhere instead of only on fixed routes
Cars can't operate everywhere so this is a unrealistic requirement in the first place.
> Do the environmental math on that -- how full does a bus need to be before the pollution per passenger is better than a compact car with one passenger? How about a compact car with four passengers?
Assuming a 1 person/car with a average 19mpg, and a average bus 6.2mpg, you need 3.06 people on a bus before it breaks even.
If you can have 4 people on a compact car with four passengers, you can have a bus with 3 people on it.
Also note that your other examples violate my overarching point which is that they're about externalities. They don't represent advantages to the users' near term needs/desires, and in the case of my personal feelings about cyclists are actively in opposition, so they're almost always going to be fighting an uphill battle for mass acceptance.
Variable? A single line of rail moves more people per hour that 6 lanes of highway - that's just physics.
Average speed of London traffic is 10 km/h while the new Elizabeth Line wooshes past at 90 km/h. It can cross London before your car gets 1/3 of the way.
A crowded train still moves at 90 km/h. Your car in a jam is personally comfortable (unless you need to take a piss), but doesnt move anywhere.
The idea that cars are comparable to public transport in situations of gridlock is preposterous.
I don't especially want alternatives to be more popular; I want less carbon and fewer cars. If that means making cars shittier (than they already are), then that's good in my book.
> Make it private, without the need to be crammed into a box with strangers
People who can't stand "strangers" should pay a special tax for being antisocial. Society is nothing if not sharing space with strangers.
But I and many others who commute to Vienna don't want to go back to commuting by public transport. Been there, done that - in one direction, it's 1.5h by train + 2 metro lines, vs. 30-40 mins by car. It's an absolute no brainer, I will not waste 3h per day (!!) commuting.
To the helpful suggestions of "finding a home closer to work", I can only say: and what do I so in some years when I change jobs? Move again? No thanks!
Public transport is great if the factors align, but honestly, with the travel times that I have, I wouldn't use it even if they made it free of charge.
Well, because the parties who try to do that (e.g. Greens in europe) immediately get out-voted out of office once the population starts to notice the permanent traffic jams.
But it's not for a lack of trying -- they put measures like reducing speed limits in cities, reducing car lanes, etc.