> Cue an hours-long conversation about philosophy and language.
Only among people who aren't linguists.
Of course, a lot of philosophy is merely confusion about language.
> Cue an hours-long conversation about philosophy and language.
Only among people who aren't linguists.
Of course, a lot of philosophy is merely confusion about language.
This is an example of a dummy pronoun, which is syntactically required even though it doesn't provide any meaning. We could have avoided this discussion if English were a pronoun-dropping language, like Japanese, which is why this is philosophically a bit shallow: Deep philosophy doesn't depend on what language I happen to speak.
Hey, it looks like even linguists don’t all agree. From the wiki:
Some linguists such as D. L. Bolinger go even further, claiming that the "weather it" simply refers to a general state of affairs in the context of the utterance. In this case, it would not be a dummy word at all. Possible evidence for this claim includes exchanges such as:
"Was it nice (out) yesterday?" "No, it rained." where it is implied to mean "the local weather".
Good to know Wittgenstein is still posting.