Also, it doesn't explain why the plan to help with elevated fuel prices involved borrowing money to pay the companies rather than trying to windfall tax them so that their profits aren't so excessive.
The actual reason that Labour's plan could be mostly funded from windfall taxes was much more cynical: it ended in April back when energy prices were expected to be even higher then, whilst the government plan extended for two years and cost substantially more as a result. It couldn't just be extended for longer either because a huge chunk of the money came from backdating windfall taxes as far as possible. This worked for Labour because the media was willing to ignore what this would actually mean for consumers - something they didn't do when the Government inevitably caved and did the same thing themselves. Of course, now that April is coming Rachel Reeves and other Labour politicians are claiming that the reason energy prices are going up is because the Tories refused to impose proper windfall taxes and of course Labour would keep the cap past then, and the BBC and others are repeating that claim unchallenged too.
> Companies can reduce their payments if they invest capital in new production in the North Sea – covering everything from hiring vessels and rigs to engineering contracts.
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/02/why-is-shel...
I don't know why you're going on about Labour - how are they relevant?
The first UK windfall tax targeted on oil companies was in 1983 under Thatcher / Lord Lawson; so the party that recommends it depends more on what oil prices are doing rather than whether there is a left or right government in power.
Whether it will or won't cover all the costs doesn't really matter either, because everyone knows what the quality of economic forecasts are variable at best; you can't control an economy (no matter how much some Communist governments tried), but you can influence it with taxes / subsidies. What matters is the benefits and costs.
The main issue is that the UK economy is suffering under supply side inflation, and the usual tricks don't really work too well. The BoE have to be careful as during stagflation rate changes have larger than normal impacts; far more of a tightrope that usual. The UK has several supply side issues beyond other countries; no natural gas reserves (they were sold by the Tories / Osborne), and Brexit. And so the UK is in a tighter strait jacket; and the current results / forecasts for the GDP reflect that.
This drop in investment leads to a drop in output which leads to a drop in tax revenue which leads to a drop in the currency (external/forex, internal/inflation). Brexit certainly hasn't helped at all on the investment front (either internal or FDI); plenty of UK businesses are investing in a presence in the EU so they can keep selling to EU customers (which leads to EU employment and EU taxes).
But cuts in services for the working class leads to a less productive working class (on top of the productivity hit from reduced capital investment), and real terms wage cuts leads to a real terms tax revenue cut as well (ceteris paribus; which it rarely is, the Tories want to tax the rich less which makes even less sense, the beatings will continue until morale improves!).
Stagflation is hard enough to navigate through without wearing ideological blinkers.