Is that actually a thing? I read the Capital quite a long time ago but I don’t think Marx advocated for any of that. He wrote about workers’ ownership of the means of production and how they should be the ones deciding what to do with the results of their labour.
In a market economy, that would lead to workers-owned companies, so the people deciding salaries and compensations would be the employees. How revenue is split is still a strategic decision: you still need war chests for difficult times, investments, etc. You’d hope that the pay would be more fair, but it’s a consequence of the employees taking decisions, rather something postulated a priori.
> Self-employment is a good way to take on more risk for (potentially) higher pay.
Indeed. And some people really like it, which is great. But you obviously cannot do the same thing as a one-man shop than as a large company. A working economy needs both, otherwise the plucky independents quickly get out of things like manufactured goods and food. Also, for some people stability is more important, and sometimes both sets of people are the same at different points in their lives. It is not really a good argument against fair wages.
> Before anyone counters with "but what about unskilled workers who can't self-employ", I would return the question - yes, what about them?
This sounds fine and dandy until they take a rifle and get off you what they need to survive. The simple truth is that people are not going to just starve because you think they don’t deserve a living.
> I see no particular reason why profit of a company must be shared with its workers, most of whom did not outlay the initial capital (or subsequent funding rounds) that built the company.
OTOH, capital itself does not build anything or produce anything. You need people to actually do the work at some point, and they are at least as necessary and important as the rich dude who signed a check at the beginning. Never mind the fact that “investors” who get rich off the secondary market do not bring anything to the company of which they trade the shares. I do it as well at my (very modest) level, but I don’t pretend I am doing anything useful by buying and selling stock.