As you "catch it" in some inconsistency and antagonize it, you're guiding it to complete a new document where you play the role of accuser and it plays the role of buffoon or denier. The more aggravated or clever you get, the more innane and stubborn it gets. Not because it's an intelligent agent trying to hide something but because that's what this sort of dialog generally looks like in its training data and with the seeded context it starts with ("helpful AI, doesn't know current stuff", etc).
It doesn't know what the f--- is going on because it doesn't know anything. It's just trying to complete a dialog that looks the way you're hinting that it should look.
Hopefully, experiences like this can be explained to people so that they understand how simple and limited it actually is. It's not "intelligent" or "a liar" or any such thing -- it's just a committed improvisor with a big (enormous) catalog of text samples to reference when composing a creative dialog with you.