Arguing if a new tech is legal is like saying the Earth is flat.
Arguing that we can create and alter the laws and should therefore be discussing if we want this tech to be legal, that's like saying the Earth is a sphere.
Both are wrong, but treating them as equivalent is even more wrong than both of them.
> You can't make any law you want, and keep a free society. You can't tell people they can't train neural nets with publicly available data. You can't tell people they can't run something like stable diffusion without getting output approved by some approved entity.
Depends what you count as "a free society".
There are things which I'm not allowed to take photographs of or record videos of, such as the screen of a cinema while it's playing the latest superhero film.
There are communications I am not allowed to make, such as the sequence of bits required to recreate even an approximation of the new song from that famous pop singer everyone likes.
There is data I'm not allowed to be given or store, like a random stranger's medical records.
You're allowed to be an anarchist and say those things should be legal, but most people don't really care very much about any of that — closest we get is people campaigning to "keep memes legal".
Hmm.
I'm no lawyer, but there's probably one here: what even is the legal status of companies selling the service of searchable archives of screenshots with text on them and short video clips? Is that "fair use" or "probably copyright infringement but nobody cares" or "they all need to be licensed, there was a court case"? (I assume it varies by jurisdiction, an answer in any will do).