On Being the Ideal Reader of Tom Wolfe’s School of New Journalism (2018)
newyorker.com
newyorker.com
A book like The Right Stuff seems pretty rooted in historical reality but you could never be too sure when it departed.
From the article: """ the "Hectoring Narrator," who might talk to or insult the characters; the "Downstage Voice," through which Wolfe would adopt the tone and vocabulary of one of his characters in a paragraph of background or history; and his famous use of punctuation. """
I enjoyed this when I first read Wolfe years ago, but with the latest one I read a few years ago, my feeling was "Get your elbow out of my ribs. If I'm not laughing, it isn't because I don't get the joke, it's that the joke isn't that great."
This style of nonfiction drives me absolutely bonkers. Often it is more about the author and their experiences than the thing they are puporting to write about, as if the author's subjective experiences are somehow the thing that others will find most interesting. Sometimes they are, if the author is particularly talented and has been somewhere particularly interesting, but usually they aren't. To use the phrase that Tom Wolfe coined, it is "the Me generation" in writing form.
I see this style today in a lot of the "long form" journalism, and usually comes across as the author trying to say in 5,000 words what could probably said in 500.
Just the relevant facts, please.
It’s ok if you don’t enjoy this, but I think your comment has a note of suggesting inferiority rather than just preference, and I think that’s off the mark.
The only time I’ve found it useful is good gonzo journalism where the mental scene is important context. E.g. Hunter S. Thompson drug stories or stories of mystical experiences. In these articles a focus on subjective experience is necessary. For articles about things, it’s just a waste of words.