I didn't preach that, I purposely left out where the first one works and what the industry is. In all honesty, you have to admit you filled out that part yourself so you can have something to argue about :)
No, it's not about corporate loyalty at all but I don't have any means to dissuade you so you'll just have to trust me on this (or don't).
You purposely skipped the part where one person is honest and good at what they do while the other is the opposite.
> the nice guy you're talking about had job pay increases exceeding inflation at each 3 jobs over 20 years
The smart guy did not rely only on pay increases, you're thinking too small about financial compensation. Salary is not the only source of compensation. There are other, better financial models to keep the expert employee and to grow alongside said expert and to keep every party happy. Win for engineer, win for employer and win for customer _is_ a possible scenario.