Here's some more reading if you're interested: https://www.anandtech.com/show/17641/lighter-touch-cpu-power...
Here's some more reading if you're interested: https://www.anandtech.com/show/17641/lighter-touch-cpu-power...
Cinebench R23 multithread:
Ryzen 7950X 230 -> 125 watts = 95%
Ryzen 7950X 230 -> 105 watts = 93%
Ryzen 7950X 230 -> 65 watts = 81%
Intel I9-13900k 253 watts -> 125 watts = 78%
Intel I9-13900k 253 watts -> 105 watts = 72%
Intel I9-13900k 253 watts -> 65 watts = 56%
Other benchmarks like C-ray show ZERO slowdown going from 230 -> 125 and even 105 watts. Intel drops by 21% for 125 watts and 30% for 105 watts.Personally I'd rather get the 7900X (or non-x) and you'd keep an even larger fraction of the performance within a given power limit. It's pretty clear who has the worse core and has to push harder into high clock/terrible power usage for not much gain curve.
Also keep in mind that "performance mode" on Intel can significantly increase the default 253 watt TDP. Anandtech reviews of the i9-13900k hit 380 watts I believe.
So sure there's chip to chip variation, but generally the AMD chips are more power efficient and have much lower penalties for reducing the TDP.
I've been playing around with the 13900K's settings and so far I've managed to get it down to a stable 210W TDP(according to XTU under stress testing. That's with a 0.110V undervolt(likely could do more) and the P-core turbo multipliers tapering down to 50 with all cores active from 57 with 1 core active. I've yet to mess with the E-cores though; could probably shave off some more perf/W still.
The system idles at half the wattage, too—so it's saving a ton of energy not running at the stock 170W TDP. Not sure why AMD didn't go for efficiency crown, especially for non-halo SKUs like the 7950.
Happy to be proven wrong, because it is a brilliant idea. My machine is wildly oversized for my typical usage, and I could easily take a 10%+ performance haircut and likely would not even notice.
But if you use these chips for tasks that max out all cores for several hours per day, it may be better the simply run a chip with more cores and to run those in econ mode. A 7950X@64W may perform as well as a 7900X@200W for such compute tasks, and are probably cheaper over time.
And if you use it in your house, they generate less noise, can use a cheaper cooler and doesn't dump so much heat into your room.
99.99% of the population doesn't know this option exists.
And 0.01% want BIGGER NUMBERS OMG 720FPS!!! and ruin power consumption worldwide for everyone else.
Which is unfortunate, because when it comes to benchmarks, understanding the context of a test setup is extraordinarily important. Are you buying that very high-end memory the test setup used and then manually adjusting timings? No? Then you're not getting those numbers. Heck, you may be losing 20% or more performance compared to the test rig on just the difference in memory. Never mind adjusting other things, ensuring the system's thermals are entirely kept in check to prevent throttling, etc.
This already happened in previous generations (especially Zen2).
AMD has to play this stupid game, unfortunately, because the press is what it is.
As you should. I worked at Intel back in the 00s when they were in the "megahertz wars". All they talked about internally was "we're winning the MHz wars!!! Yay!". When anyone mentioned power consumption, or how fucking loud the cooling fans were, or MIPS/Watt, they didn't care; all that mattered was MHz. Hitching their wagon to RAMBUS memory was part of this. Then they got pissed and indignant when consumers didn't want to spend a fortune on RAMBUS memory and bought AMD CPUs with cheap SDRAM instead.
I wrote a few microbenchmarks to explore the performance promises of rambus, and didn't find anything.