they pretend to be like minds – like human minds. But it is only pretend, there is no mind there and that is the key to understanding what ChatGPT is
And surely they have no mind like us. But this obsession with whether or not it is like us, seems to miss the point, doesn't it. Is it useful? Despite the writers insistence that it is not, my children provide my with many examples that it is.
For example, my daughter is learning to program and got negative feedback on her commenting style. (which admittedly where mostly absent) So, she asked how to do it better. The teacher gave only non-committal responses, like being helpful to the reader, etc. It is not the kind of instruction that is helpful for her. So she gave the whole program the ChatGTP and asked it to insert comments without changing the code. The next day, she took the output to the teacher and asked if this is what he meant. It was perfect. But now, she knows what is expected of her, and now she can do it without ChatGTP.