It can be quite scary - what's the minimum population count needed to sustain colony species?
We depend on so much infrastructure to stay alive, and have so few survival skills I would guess that even quite a large population (few million) would die out if they were scattered throughout the world.
Look at how the passenger pigeon went from the most numerous bird in North America to extinct in 10 years, purely because the minimum number to keep the colony alive was breached.
What happened next can only be described as explosive growth.
Maybe, but we were, as a species, a lot less specialised, and so individuals could succeed with smaller numbers.
The other part you are missing is that we no longer have access to the low-hanging fruit in terms of natural resources.
In 1900 we could subsist because we had a lot more natural resources simply lying around, or close to the surface. We used those up. We razed down countrysides, replaced with non-fertile concrete.
We have almost nothing right now that cannot run on electricity, which requires experts in multiple fields to harvest and distribute.
The majority of humans in 1900 were mostly self-sufficient, those who weren't starved to death. The majority of humans now are clearly nowhere near to self-sufficient if infrastructure starts to decay due to insufficient experts.
Remember, I did not say it will be scary, I said it can be a scary thought.
This thought keeps me up at night sometimes. I’m nearly 40 with no kids, nieces/nephews, and even my cousins are mostly childless.
Our eldercare models are already beginning to buckle under the strain of the retiring Boomers - and they still overwhelmingly have family/church/pensions as primary non-govt support structures.
You can’t paper over this with immigration either. There will be absolutely no political will power to saddle millions of productive first/second gen immigrants with the sort of crippling tax burden the state would need to “replace” a total loss of the family/church/pension support triad. Expecting a huge push towards “medical assistance in dying” (MAID) seems to be a safe bet.
Tl;dr: the current elder care system prioritizes “old maids” but the future system will undoubtedly be “the Olds get MAID”
Even if we successfully turn the trend around there'll still be a generational gap that will cause a series of smaller generations going forward.
So imo, it’s not 2020s grandkid-wanting Boomers/GenX going “you’re on your own, kid” so much as it’s their greedy younger selves getting manipulated into mortgaging their eventual children’s future away in the 80s and 90s.
A distinction without a difference I guess, but the root of this problem stems from the Reagan/Clinton eras and not many people seem interested in discussing how we can successfully roll back some of the more egregious anti-worker legal/regulatory changes from those days.
There's a lot to admire in the boomers I think, they had a great culture, and they contributed a massive amount of technological and scientific progress as well. But agree they never had the competition these newer generations are facing and so did not do enough to prepare their kids for a more competitive world (I mean, some did, but not enough).
Yeah it’s still not too late for this sort of thing in the West. Though the cynic in me thinks it’s very unlikely the political class travels the idealogical axis from today’s mostly explicit anti-natalism to having the political willpower necessary for implementing pro-family policies.
At least we have a chance. Places like South Korea/Japan might as well change their national mottos to “omae wa mou shindeiru”
So if people organically decide (or due to this sperm count thing are forced) to have fewer kids, this is really a brilliant thing for the planet.
This narrative has been popular, especially among wealthy, educated, people for a long long time. But most of it is hogwash.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Population_Bomb#Prediction...
We can overcome problems like climate change without considering ourselves to be a virus that needs to be controlled like that.
However it's ok, a lot of people are going to lose their jobs due to automation anyway, leaving more people free for healthcare. It will not be easy but we'll cope. And we have to in order not to burn up this planet.
Not just rural or even conservative USA: my mom lives in a city that would be in the top 5 of everyone’s “Name the most liberal city in America” list.
She had major surgery right before Covid and her church had people bringing her flowers and keeping her company nearly every day while she was an inpatient - and then had a coordinated rotating list of church members bringing home cooked dinners and visiting her every day for several weeks while she recuperated at home.
I expect this sort of thing will largely die with the Boomers and we’ll join our Euro-brethren in the bubbling soup of cynicism and lowered expectations
That it'll work out badly for me, that's true but overall it's necessary.
I share your view that human populations need a natural stabilization (and we've found it, by combining urban living with available birth control).
It's been too long since I looked into this issue, and I'm at work so don't have time to do the research now, but I remember studies showing that declining sperm count is a problem across multiple species.