Should a Christian website be allowed to foster a Christian community, without disruptive trolls? Should a Republican website be allowed to create a Republican eco chamber? Should Reddit be liable for the moderator of a food community removing a post about android tech support? Should sites where dang censors whatever he wants for the sake of the community values suddenly become liable for the speech that isn’t removed?
No. It’s my speech not his.
Let’s be real, the threat of benevolent censorship is what keeps this place civil and upstanding.
You might say, but but transparency. Now you are creating a new problem. For example, the Christian website above. If I go there extolling the virtues of Satan, you are forcing them to host copies of speech they find deplorable, in their public censorship reports. And if you obscure or roll up censorship reports, now you need independent speech removal auditors.
I would choose a better spam filter and a free market for you to make a competing service with transparency. The free market breaks down when institutions become proprietary and monolithic.
A better angle is the government to better force protocols, decentralization, federation etc. Even email is kinda controlled by two players, but at least if I got kicked off one I can still email all my old friends from my new account on the other. Data portability, service interoperability, and privacy better address a lack of transparency than forcing homogenous censorship rules on all sites.