That's some wishful thinking if I've ever seen one.
That's some wishful thinking if I've ever seen one.
Like yes in a perfect world time saved would go back to workers, it doesn't though.
A machine could do in a minute what a knitter would do in a day, it doesn't mean knitters got a 7 minute work week
That’s why the capitalist class owns the means of production (the owner makes their profit in 7 minutes now).
I believe that means in a very real sense that the time saved has gone back to workers. We all already share in that collective productivity increase.
This is why in the US there are hordes of homeless people with smart phones and why the poor generally have no problem having houses full of appliances and giant TVs. Gadgets have indeed gotten radically cheaper.
The things that are hard to make cheaper for structural or physical reasons like housing, health care, tuition, and child care tend to inflate so as to eat the surplus. Housing is the worst culprit in many markets.
Much earlier. Special skills and inventions giving you business, military or social advantages have been a thing since special skills and inventions have been a thing.
I benefit from invention of a car because I can buy a car and be it's owner and only benefactor
You cannot buy and own ChatGPT as invididual, you will never even be able to inslect its source code.
A car is patent protected. Patents allow me personally to build a car for my personal use. Copyright doesn't allow that.
Patents last 20 years, copyright lasts close to 100, depending on jurisdiction.
The only reason corporations can make insane profits from this tech is because we granted this category of IP insane priviliges and government is spending tax dollars to protect their IP.
Make code like patents - it must be published in a register accessibke by anyone, and loses protections after 20 years.
If you don't register it, then the government will not be prosecuting anyone for using it.
Suddenly the benefits will be shared
However I believe Art belongs under copyright. It us not functional - our society does not fall apart is a famous piece of art is lost.
However our society does fall apart when key piece of technology is lost, thats why Patents have all these safeguards. Code is functional technology, it is not merely artistic.
It's the menial work that gets offloaded to machines. I don't see current AI coming up with new ideas for example.
I'd check that carefully before relying on it. I've personally used AI to come up with new ideas for a few projects I'm working on. I've read several articles detailing how people are using it to innovate in their business and I'm 100% certain the reason why ChatGPT is at capacity during working hours every day is because there are droves of people using it daily for work now. I'd even go as far as to say that brainstorming with ChatGPT is one of the most productive use cases.
It seems that you basically agree with the point being made. You are coming up with those ideas with help of ChatGPT as a tool, or is the bot coming up with ideas? If it's the latter, can we remove you from the process and achieve the same result?
I don't think so, but I am not saying this will never happen in the future, though.
I'm sure at some point they'll get past that point but it seems a tough nut to crack with current tech.
> Those jobs all disappeared but do we really miss them?
That's basically true, but consider this; right now, some people would vote for candidates who bring back coal mining just to restore their jobs and income. This is easy in hindsight of a couple of centuries, but very challenging at the time.