I would go one step further and say that donations to religious organizations should not be tax deductible. They are not charities in 99% of the cases.
The problem is that it doesn't do $32B worth of charitable work. Or anything close to it. And that, I think, is the problem.
So we have, or have had, tax policies in the US that encourage home ownership, marriage, donations to charity, long-term investment, purchasing electric vehicles or electrifying your house, and more. The results of each of these is mixed, and sometimes contentious, but they're all there because congress decided at one point or another that a thing was worth encouraging or discouraging.
I can easily argue that citizenry being directly involved in directing their funds to causes that matter is more democratic than the government doing that on their behalf.